Investing in breastfeeding support may help reduce social inequalities
1 July 2022
Breastfeeding matters for children’s cognitive development, but disadvantaged mothers who give birth at the weekend are less likely to breastfeed, owing to poorer breastfeeding support in hospitals, finds a new UCL study.
![East Asian mother breastfeeding her baby. Image: anekoho / Adobe Stock East Asian mother breastfeeding her baby. Image: anekoho / Adobe Stock](https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/sites/ioe/files/styles/large_image/public/breastfeeding-east-asian-baby.png?itok=mI-k_Mgj)
The new research, published in the American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, found that children, born in 2000-02, whose mothers left school before age 17 and who were breastfed for at least three months, gained higher scores in cognitive assessments up to age 7 than those from similar backgrounds who weren’t breastfed. The researchers from UCL Economics and IOE, UCL’s Faculty of Education and Society, suggest that improving breastfeeding support for disadvantaged mothers may benefit their children’s cognitive development.
Co-author, Professor Emla Fitzsimons (Centre for Longitudinal Studies at UCL) said: “Given the importance of breastfeeding for cognitive development, this research raises the question as to how we can best support disadvantaged mothers who wish to breastfeed but are struggling to do so. The importance of providing hands on infant feeding support in maternity wards should not be under-estimated, and follow-up support in the early days is vital too.”
The researchers analysed data collected from a nationally representative group of almost 6,000 children born across the UK in 2000-02 whose mothers left school before age 17 and who had a natural or low risk delivery. The sample was drawn from the Millennium Cohort Study (MCS), a longitudinal study which has been following the lives of around 19,000 children since they were born.
When they were 9 months old, their mothers were asked whether they had breastfed and for how long. At 9 months, 3, 5 and 7, they reported whether their children had any health problems, and from age 3, they also reported on their children’s emotional development. At ages 3, 5 and 7, children undertook a series of cognitive assessments. The research did not observe children’s health while they were still being breastfed.
The study analysed the effects of breastfeeding durations of at least three months, close to the recommended duration at the time of their infancy, compared to those who breastfed for a shorter duration than this or not at all.
Among disadvantaged mothers, those who gave birth at the weekend were around six percentage points less likely to breastfeed for at least 90 days than those who gave birth during the week. For example, 27% of disadvantaged mothers who gave birth on Monday went on to breastfeed their children, compared to only 21% of those who gave birth on Saturday.
Lower educated mothers of children born on a Friday or Saturday were less satisfied with infant feeding advice obtained in hospital compared to mothers of Monday-borns, according to data taken from the Maternity Users Survey 2007. Neither pattern – differences in rates of breastfeeding and hospital feeding support by timing of birth – existed for mothers who had stayed on in education past secondary school.
Children who were breastfed for at least 90 days gained, on average, 8% higher scores in cognitive tests during childhood than those from similar homes who weren’t breastfed, scoring particularly higher in school readiness and speech and vocabulary assessments. The study found no statistically significant benefits from breastfeeding on health or emotional development for this group, up to age 7. However, the research was unable to assess whether breastfeeding had other health benefits, such as increased immunity against disease.
Co-author, Professor Marcos Vera-Hernández (UCL Economics) said: “This new study shows that children of lower educated mothers who are born at the weekend are less likely to be breastfed compared to those born during the week. They also tend to score worse in cognitive assessments to age 7. As core maternity services for low risk births remain consistent throughout the week, our study shows that it is differences in support for breastfeeding on the weekend that makes the difference.”
The study uses a novel approach to understanding the causal impact of breastfeeding on cognitive development, by using variation in day of the week of birth among natural births to estimate the gains in children’s later development due to breastfeeding. The research provides extensive evidence to rule out other factors that might vary by day of birth, such as maternal and birth-related characteristics, which are shown not to vary by timing of birth, nor do a range of other hospital maternity services. Therefore any differences observed in children’s subsequent development can plausibly be attributed to breastfeeding.
Links
- Read the full report
- The Millennium Cohort Study
- Centre for Longitudinal Studies
- UCL Social Research Institute
- UCL Economics
Image: anekoho / Adobe Stock