Vaccine effectiveness wanes after three months among care home residents
18 March 2022
Vaccination-acquired immunity against Covid-19 wanes substantially after three months among elderly care home residents, suggesting that regular booster jabs may be needed for this group, according to preliminary findings from the Vivaldi study led by UCL researchers.
The study, funded by the UK Health Security Agency and published on the preprint site medRxiv, looked at data from over 15,000 residents (with a median age of 87) and 19,000 staff at 331 care homes across England from December 2020 to December 2021.
The researchers found that two vaccine doses were effective at preventing 85.4% of hospitalisations and 94.4% of deaths among care home residents between two and 12 weeks after the second dose, but that this fell to 54.3% of hospitalisations and 62.89% of deaths at three to seven months after vaccination.
Looking at booster jabs given in the autumn, the researchers found they restored powerful short-term immunity, reducing hospitalisations among residents by 89.9% and deaths by 97.5% compared to pre-vaccination levels. However, they cautioned that this protection was likely to wane in a similar way to the protection provided by first and second doses.
Professor Laura Shallcross (UCL Institute of Health Informatics), leader of the UCL-led Vivaldi team, said: “Our data suggests that repeated booster jabs may be needed to protect elderly care home residents in future, as immunity wanes relatively quickly in this group following vaccination.
“We observe an increased risk of infection, hospital admission and death in residents as early as 12 weeks following vaccination. This underscores the critical need for continued surveillance in care homes to provide an early warning of surges in infection linked to new variants or waning immunity.
“Our data stops before Omicron became dominant, but it is likely this pattern of diminishing immunity after vaccination will continue with this milder variant.”
Dr Maddie Shrotri (UCL Institute of Health Informatics), lead author of the study, said: “Our study shows three vaccine doses maximise immunity against infection and severe Covid-19 for both care home residents and staff, including those with previous infection. However, given the waning of immunity among residents, it will be important to consider how this vulnerable group can continue to be protected against Covid-19 whilst ensuring global vaccine equity.”
In the study, researchers evaluated the effectiveness of first, second and third doses of vaccination among residents and staff over a one-year period, using national data from PCR testing carried out two to three times a month, as well as hospitalisations and death registrations data. They took account of how the infection rate varied over time to ensure an accurate measure of the vaccine effects.
Among staff with a median age of 45, the researchers found only a slight fall in vaccine effectiveness, with a 50% reduced risk of infection between two and 12 weeks after the jab and 42.1% reduced risk of infection after 12 weeks. After a third booster vaccination, staff had a 78.3% reduced risk of infection and their risk of hospitalisation was reduced by 95.8%.
The study found that levels of protection following an mRNA (Pfizer or Moderna) booster dose were similar regardless of whether the first two doses were Oxford-AstraZeneca or mRNA vaccines.
The new research is part of the ongoing Vivaldi study, launched in June 2020, to investigate SARS-CoV-2 infections in care homes and to answer questions about immunity and vaccine effectiveness, helping to inform strategies to protect residents. Vivaldi involves researchers from the University of Birmingham and is being delivered in partnership with care providers.
- Preprint study
- Vivaldi project
- Professor Laura Shallcross’s academic profile
- Dr Maddie Shrotri’s research profile
- UCL Institute of Health Informatics
- UCL Population Health Sciences
T: +44 (0)7990 675947
E: m.greaves [at] ucl.ac.uk