UK-wide study describes brain complications in patients with severe COVID-19
26 June 2020
Neurological and psychiatric complications observed in critically ill patients during the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, shine new light on conditions which may be linked to coronavirus, finds new research co-led by UCL.
The study, published in the Lancet Psychiatry, describes 153 patients treated in UK hospitals, who were deemed by doctors to represent the most severe cases.
In patients where there was complete data (125 individuals), serious brain complications included stroke (62%, 77) and an altered mental state such as brain inflammation, psychosis and dementia-like symptoms (31%, 39).
While it is not possible to draw conclusions about the total proportion of COVID-19 patients likely to be affected with similar complications, researchers say the report offers the first detailed snapshot of the breadth of neurological conditions in COVID-19 patients and should help direct future research to establish the mechanisms of such complications so that treatments can be developed.
Co-author, Professor Sarah Pett (UCL Institute for Clinical Trials and Methodology) said: “This data represents an important snapshot of the brain-related complications of COVID-19 in hospitalised patients. It is critically important that we continue to collect this information to really understand this virus fully.
"We also need to understand brain-complications in people in the community who have COVID-19 but were not sick enough to be hospitalised. Our study provides the foundations for larger, hospital and community-based studies. These studies will help inform on the frequency of these brain complications, who’s most at risk of getting them, and ultimately how best to treat."
Lead author, Dr Benedict Michael (University of Liverpool) said: “There have been growing reports of an association between COVID-19 infection and possible neurological or psychiatric complications, but until now these have typically been limited to studies of ten patients or fewer. Ours is the first nation-wide study of neurological complications associated with COVID-19, but it is important to note that it is focused on cases that are severe enough to require hospitalisation.”
Increasingly, concerns regarding potential neurological complications of COVID-19 are being reported. However, most published reports have been limited to individual cases or small case series and even larger studies have been limited by both geography and specialty. Consequently, many important questions remain, such as how common complications are, whether novel syndromes are emerging, and which people are most at risk.
To address this, the CoroNerve Studies Group, a collaboration between UCL and the universities of Liverpool, Southampton, Newcastle, set up a secure UK-wide online network for specialist doctors to report details of specific cases. These portals are hosted by professional bodies representing specialists in neurology, stroke, psychiatry and intensive care. These first data was collected between 2 April and 26 April 2020, during the exponential phase of the pandemic.
Some 153 cases were reported during this first study period, of which full clinical details were available for 125 patients. The study included patients with confirmed COVID-19 infection by PCR test (114 people), probable infection as diagnosed from chest X-rays or CT scans (6 people), and possible infection, where patients had symptoms consistent with disease but diagnostic tests were either negative or not done (5 people).
The most common brain complication observed was stroke, which was reported in 77 of 125 patients. Of these, 57 patients had a stroke caused by a blood clot in the brain, known as an ischaemic stroke, nine patients had a stroke caused by a brain haemorrhage, and one patient had a stroke caused by inflammation in the blood vessels of the brain. Age data was available for 74 of the patients who experienced a stroke and the majority were over 60 years of age (82%, 61/77).
39 patients showed signs of confusion or changes in behaviour reflecting an altered mental state. Of these, nine patients had unspecified brain dysfunction, known as encephalopathy, and seven patients had inflammation of the brain, medically termed encephalitis. Long-term follow-up studies to assess duration and severity of these complications are needed.
The remaining 23 patients with an altered mental state were diagnosed with psychiatric conditions, of which the vast majority were determined as new diagnoses by the notifying psychiatrist (92%, 21/23). Although most psychiatric diagnoses were determined as new by the notifying psychiatrist or neuropsychiatrist, the researchers say they cannot exclude the possibility that these were undiagnosed before the patient developed COVID-19.
The 23 patients with psychiatric diagnoses included ten patients with a new-onset psychosis and six patients with a dementia-like syndrome. Seven patients had signs of a mood disorder, including depression and anxiety (7/23).
Age information was available for 37 of the 39 patients with an altered mental state and of those, around half were aged under 60 years of age (49%, 18/37).
The researchers say the high proportion of younger patients diagnosed with psychiatric conditions after showing signs of an altered mental state could be because these patients may be more likely to be referred to a psychiatrist or other specialist doctor, whereas confusion or behaviour changes in older patients may be more likely to be attributed to delirium and not investigated further.
Detailed long-term studies are needed in order to confirm if there is any link between COVID-19 infection and the onset of psychiatric or neuropsychiatric complications in younger patients. Such studies should include comparison of the immune response in affected patients and those not affected, as well as investigation of genetic factors that might underpin the development of disease, the researchers say.
Dr Michael added: “Our study is an important early step towards defining neurological complications in COVID-19 patients, which will help with health policy planning as well as informing the immediate next steps in COVID-19 neuroscience research. We now need detailed studies to understand the possible biological mechanisms underlying these complications so that we can explore potential treatments.”
The researchers are supported by grants from the Medical Research Council, Wellcome, National Institute of Health Research and Academy of Medical Sciences.
- Research paper published in Lancet Psychiatry
- Professor Sarah Pett's academic profile
- UCL Institute for Clinical Trials and Methodology
- University of Liverpool
- Newcastle University
- University of Southampton
- CoroNerve Studies Group
- 'Computed tomography of human brain'. Credit: wikimedia commons CC BY 2.0
- The Lancet
Tel: +4 (0) 7881 833274
E: h.killworth [at] ucl.ac.uk