Adults can be retrained to learn second languages more easily
14 June 2005
Our ability to hear and understand a second language becomes more and more difficult with age, but the adult brain can be retrained to pick up foreign sounds more easily again. This finding, reported by Dr Paul Iverson of the UCL Centre for Human Communication, at the “Plasticity in Speech Perception 2005” workshop - builds on an important new theory that the difficulties we have with learning languages in later life are not biological and that, given the right stimulus, the brain can be retrained.
It is an accepted fact that the younger the child, the easier it is for them to learn a second language. Children are able to understand words and hear small sound differences that adults often miss – making understanding more difficult for adults. For example, Polish students of English have difficulty differentiating between vowels such as “pen” and “pan” while German students must learn to hear a difference between the v in “vest” and the w in “west”.
Scientists used to believe that the adult brain could not be retrained later in life to distinguish between these sounds: in other words the brain’s plasticity (or ability to change) was set.
Dr Iverson shows that adults can retune their brains to hear these differences again. Scientists now believe that the difficulties are caused by our experience which teaches us to ignore certain sounds so that we are able to give our full attention to the sounds that (in our native language) matter most to understanding a sentence.
Two studies jointly worked on by Dr Paul Iverson and Dr Valerie Hazan, UCL’s Department of Phonetics and Linguistics, have examined whether it is possible to retune how the brain processes speech sounds, and hope that their findings will help make language learning easier for adults. In one study, Japanese subjects were retrained to hear the difference between r’s and l’s (something that Japanese students of English tend to find particularly difficult). The study tested 63 native Japanese subjects in Japan and London, and had them complete a 10-session training course. Before and after training, the subjects were given a number of perceptual tests to evaluate their perception of acoustic cues. Similar tests were carried out in London on Sinhalese (from Sri Lanka) and German speakers who had lived in the UK for more than 20 years.
In the Japanese training study, the subjects improved their recognition of l’s and r’s by an average of 18% percentage points. So, for example, if an individual could identify the difference between r and l 60% of the time, at the end of training they would be able to get this correct 78% of the time - supporting the view that the brain can be retuned.
Talking at the UCL workshop, which brings together specialists in language, speech and speech perception, Dr Iverson said: “Adult learning does not appear to become difficult because of a change in neural plasticity. Rather, we now think that learning becomes hard because experience with our first language 'warps' perception. We see things through the lens of our native language and that 'warps' the way we see foreign languages.
“It is very difficult to undo this learning. That is, we change our perception during childhood so that it becomes specialized to hear the speech sounds in our first language. This specialization can conflict with our ability to learn to distinguish sounds in other languages. Through training, we can essentially change our 'perceptual warping' to make second-language learning easier. I hope that this research will lead to new ways of training adults to learn second languages.”
Notes for Editors
1. The ISCA Workshop on Plasticity in Speech Perception held at UCL brings together researchers working in a number of disciplines from all around the world. Topics covered range from dyslexia and foreign language learning to cochlear implants and brain imaging.
2. Go to http://www.psp2005.org.uk/ for more information. A link to the programme of events is available on this website. Speaker summary notes are available through the website (click on programme, then delegate name)
3. Speakers at the three-day conference include:
James Flege, University of Alabama at Birmingham, on 15th June at 10am
Christophe Pallier, Inserm Cognitive Neuroimaging Unit, on 15th June at 10.30am
Sophie Scott, UCL, on 16th June at 2pm
Dr Paul Iverson, UCL, on 16th June at 4pm
David Moore, MRC Institute of Hearing Research, on 16th June at 4.30pm
4. Press wanting to attend the workshop or interview speakers can contact Alex Brew at UCL’s press office on 020 7679 9726, 07747 565 056 or firstname.lastname@example.org