PLIN0068 Constructed Languages

2023-24

Lecture 2: Phonology

Phonology

  • Traditionally phonology is about linguistic sounds
  • Now phonology includes the phonology of sign languages
  • More generally phonology is about the smallest units of linguistic form
    • Morse code (a relex): dots and dashes
    • iPad gesture language: tap, hold, swipe, pinch open, pinch close, etc.

Phonology of the pedestrian traffic light

We can see the pedestrian traffic light as a (finite) language

Red = Stop!Green = Go!Flashing green = will be Red soon

Design considerations
  • Why these colours? (not, e.g., Green vs. Blue)
  • Why not the other semantic mapping?
  • Why is Red above Green?
  • Why vertical arrangment?
  • Why flashing Green, rather than flashing Red?

Dialectal phonology of the pedestrian traffic light

Phonological universals in spoken languages

Building blocks of spoken languages

  • Phonemes/segments

  • Suprasegmental/prosodic structure

    • Syllables and feet (for accents/tones)
    • Larger intonational units

To keep our projects manageable, we won't discuss much about suprasegmental phonology, beyond some elementary aspects of syllable structure and accent.

Basic properties of consonants

  • Manner of articulation (stop, fricative, affricate, approximant, etc.)

  • Place of articulation (bilabial, labio-dentail, alveolar, palatal, velar, uvular, etc.)

  • Laryngeal features (voicing, aspiration)

Other features

  • Length (gemination)
  • Labialisation
  • Velarisation
  • Prenasalisation
  • Ejectives
  • Implosives
  • Retroflexion

Consonantal inventories

  • English has (about) 24 consonants (cf. Wikipedia)

  • Some languages have fewer than 10 consonants

    • Rotokas: /p, t, k, β, ɾ , ɡ/
    • Hawaiian: /p, k, ʔ, l, m, n, h, w/
  • Some languages have more than 80 consonants, e.g., !Xu has 95, Archi has 81.

  • Most languages have at least one fricative, nasal, and approximant
  • Some languages have no nasals (e.g., Rotokas)

Consonantal universals

  • Every language has stops
    • Most languages have voiceless stops
    • (Voiceless)Stop + Vowel sequences maximise contrast between adjecent segments
  • Every language contrasts phonemes for place of articulation
    • Languages may lack some of /p t k b d g/, especially /p/ and/or /g/
  • Every language has coronal phonemes (may lack labial or velar phonemes)
    • Coronals are loud

Consonantal contrasts

  • In some languages, voicing contrast among stops is enchanced by aspiration of the voiceless series (e.g. English), or pre-nasalisation of the voiced series (e.g., Fijian)

  • More contrasts in coronals, e.g. English fricatives /θ ð s z ʃ ʒ/

Clicks

Bilabial Dental Alveolar Palato-alveolar Lateral
ʘ ǀ ǃ ǂ ǁ

The inventory of clicks can multiply with different way of releasing

  • [g] throughout
  • [ŋ] throughout
  • release into [x]
  • release into [q]

Vowels

  • English has about 15–20 vowels, depending on the dialect; Swedish has 17

  • Some languages only have 3 vowels, e.g., Haida: /i, a, ʊ/; Pirahã: /i, a, o/.

  • Some languages contrast vowel length, in addition to quality (cf. diphthongisation)


Swedish (Engstrand 1999: p. 140)

Phonetics vs. phonology

  • Languages with a small vocalic inventory tend to have many allophones, e.g., West Greenlandic

(Fortescue 1990: p. 140)

Vocalic contrast

  • The simplest vocalic sysmtes triangular, consisting of /i a u/ or their variants
  • Larger inventories are often built open them, e.g. /i a u e o/
  • Flemming (1995, 2004): /i a u/ maximises contrast

    • As far as articulation is concerned, /y a ɯ/ is a equally sensible system
    • Rounding lowers F2, making a back vowel sound more back, so /i u/ are farther apart than /y ɯ/
  • More contrast among front vowels

(Flemming 2004)

Vertical systems

  • Vertical systems make no front-back contrast, e.g. Kabardian (/ə ɐ a/)

  • But they still have other vowels as allophones conditioned by surrounding segments, e.g. velarised consonants:

    /ts'əkw/ [ts’ukw] 'small'
    /gwədz/ [gudz] 'wheat'
    /dɐʁw/ [dɔʁw] 'thief'
    /qwɐ/ [qwɔ] 'pig'
(Gordon & Applebaum 2006: p. 182)

Kabardian consonantal inventory

The consonants in Kabardian encode part of vocalic constrast

(Gordon & Applebaum 2006: p. 161)

Secondary characteristics

  • Vowel length (short, long, over-long)
  • Diphthongisation
  • Nasalisation

These are sometimes used to enhance contrasts (e.g., English diphthongisation)

Secondary inventory

Some languages allow a subset of vowels in unstressed syllables (e.g. English, Russian)

Vocalic universals

  • Every language has a height contrast, i.e., no language has a purely horizontal system, e.g. /i, ɨ, u/, /e, ə, o/, /e, ø, o/ etc.
  • Languages may lack front vowels (e.g., Qawasqar: /ə, o, a/) and/or rounded vowels (Alawa: /ɪ, ɯ, e, a/)
  • But every language has at least one front vowel or /j/
  • Every language has at least one unrounded vowel
  • Every language has at least one back vowel

Syllable structure

  • All(?) languages have CV syllables (potential exception, Arrernte)
  • Some languages only have open syllables
  • English permists syllables of up to CCCVCCC (e.g., strengths /streŋθs/)
  • Hawaiian only has (C)V(V) syllables (5 vowels and 8 consonants), e.g.:
    • Kapalakiko 'San Francisco'
    • kepakemapa 'September'
    • Kalikimaka 'Christmas'

Syllable structure

  • Nucleus: The most sonorous element
  • Onset: Consonant(s) before the nucleus
  • Coda: Consonant(s) after the nucleus

The nucleus is typically a vowel, but need not be in some languages

  • possible in English (vs. French)
  • trh 'market' in Czech
  • Tashlhiyt Berber allows fricatives to be nuclei, e.g. k.kst.tš.št:h 'remove it an deat it' (Dell & Elmedlaoui 2002: p. 74)

Sonority scale

What can be a nucleus?

Vowels Liquids Nasals Obstruents
Kabardian, Hawaiian, Japanese
Slovak
English
Tashlhiyt Berber

Sonority Hierarchy Vowel > Approximant > Nasal > Fricative > Stop

Sonority Sequencing Principle

Sonority Sequencing Principle: Every syllable has one sonority peak

E.g., consonant clusters in English

  • great /gɹejt/ vs. rgate /ɹgejt/, clean /kliːn/ vs. lcean /lkiːn/
  • bank /bæŋk/ vs. bakn /bækŋ/, bulk /bʌlk/ vs. bulk /bʌkl/
  • /s/ is somehow special, stout, talks

Complexity

Syllable structure has an effect on how many consonants you have (Maddieson 2005)

  • Syllable complexity correlates with the number of consonants
  • Syllable complexity does not correlate with the number of vowels
  • The number of vowels does not correlate with the number of consonants

Stress

  • Languages like English use stress accent

  • A word has one syllable that is more prominent in terms of pitch, duration, intensity, etc. than the rest = primary stress

  • In quantity insensitive (fixed stress) languages, primary stress is oriented to the word edge: Initial (e.g., Hungarian, Czech), Peninitial, Antepenultimate (e.g., Macedonian), Penultimate (e.g., Polish, Fijian), Final (e.g. Armenian)

  • In quantity sensitive languages (e.g., English, Latin), heavy syllables (CVC, CVV, etc.) tend to attract primary stress

  • CVC counts as heavy in Latin but not in Yidiny

Secondary stress

  • Some syllables may carry secondary sterss, e.g. Màssachúsetts

  • Stressed and unstressed syllables usually alternate

  • A pair of stressed + unstressed syllables is called a foot

    • Iambic: [][][]
    • Trochaic: [][][]

For your language

If it's a spoken language:

  • Consonants
  • Vowels
  • Permissible syllable structures
  • Stress pattern (if it's a stress language)

Klingon phonology

Klingon

  • Klingon (a.k.a. tlhIngan Hol, /ˈt͡ɬɪ.ŋɑn xol/) was constructed by Mark Okrand, as the language of a fictional alien race, the Klingons, in Star Trek

  • Okrand has a Ph.D. in linguistics

More information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klingon_language#Phonology

Okrent (2009: Ch. 24) remarks:

The phonological system of [Klingon] is by design harsh, guttural, and alien, like Klingons, but it also makes a certain kind of linguistic sense. The language doesn't include barks, growls, or other sounds not used in human languages. And the sounds it does use are not even that exotic as far as real languages go: no clicks, trills, ingressives, or voiceless vowels.

“The goal was for the language to be as unlike human language as possible while at the same time still pronounceable by actors,” I was told by Marc Okrand, the inventor of the Klingon language. “The alien character of Klingon doesn't stem so much from the sounds it uses as from the way that it violates the rules of commonly co-occurring sounds. There's nothing extraordinary about the sounds from a linguistic standpoint. You just wouldn't expect to find them all in the same language.”

Consonants and vowels

plosive voiceless phthqhɁ
voiced bɖ
affricate voiceless t͡ɬt͡ʃq͡χ
voiced d͡ʒ
fricative voiceless ʂx
voiced vɣ
nasal mnŋ
approximant wrlj
highɪu
midɛo
lowɑ

Syllable structure: CV(C)(C)

  • A syllable must have an onset consonant
  • A syllable must have one and only one vowel
  • A syllable often has a coda consonant or two

Example words:

  • /thɑ/ 'record'
  • /thɑr/ 'poison'
  • /thɑrɣ/ 'targ (a type of animal)'

Stress is largely predictable (see Wikipedia)

Sign language phonology

Building blocks of sign languages

  • Sign language phonology is much less studied

  • Signs contrast in:

    • Handshape
    • Place of articulation (e.g., chin vs. forehead)
    • Movement (e.g., vertical vs. horizontal)
    • Orientation (of the hand(s))
(Brentari & Cormier 2018)

Prosodic Model

  • Inherent Features (1 per root)
    • Handshape (HS)
    • Place of articulation (POA)
  • Prosodic Features (≥1 per root)
(Brentari & Cormier 2018)

Homework

  • Phoneme inventory
  • Syllable structure (how to put phomenes together)
  • Accent/stress