From Megaliths to Metals: essays in honour of George Eogan, eds, H. Roche, E. Grogan, J. Bradley, J. Coles & B. Raftery
Oxford, Oxbow Books, 2004, 263pp. ISBN 1 84217 151 8 (£45)
The name George Eogan is not only synonymous with Irish Prehistory but also
with charm and bon homie. Through his influential teaching, George
prepared numerous students, not only products of UCD, for their future
employment in the fields of Irish, British and European archaeology and many of
them fondly pay tribute to their teacher, colleague and friend in this book of
wide-ranging essays reflecting the scope and interests of ‘the man’.
Despite the title, the volume starts in the Mesolithic with articles by
McCormick and Delaney and Woodman. Le Roux heads the (short) megalithic section
and the rest of the volume is devoted to articles on a comprehensive list of
subjects on Irish Prehistory (with emphasis on the Bronze Age). The volume ends
well into the historic period with articles on Ardmore Cathedral (Manning), the
High Cross of Kells (King) and an interesting bio-philosophical piece on Adolf
Mahr’s influence on Sean O’Riordain (Wallace). Beyond Ireland, articles focus
on France (le Roux, Cunliffe), England (Champion, Bradley & Ford), Central
Europe (Schauer, Jockenhövel, Bouzek), Iberia (Burgess & O’Connor,
Almagro-Gorbea) and Scandinavia (Coles): these truly reflect the wide-ranging
interests of the recipient. As with many Festschriften, articles in
this volume are extremely varied and range from the specific (e.g. Pit 119 at
Rathgall – Raftery; gold beads from Tumna – Cahill) to the much more
wide-ranging (e.g. Middle Bronze Age Burial traditions – Grogan; origins of the
Early Bronze Age in central Europe – Jockenhovel) with many more falling in
between. This is not a criticism but rather it is a format gives the book charm
and a wide appeal to all readers from the specialist to the interested laity.
I find reviewing Festschriften very difficult not least because the
articles are all written by recipient’s friends and colleagues and are written
with genuine fondness. Some may have been written hastily while others are more
considered. The articles in this volume certainly vary in their academic merit
however it would be ungracious to the recipient to pick out any particular
authors for either praise or criticism. The value of the book must be in the
judgement of the recipient rather than a reviewer and, of course peer citation
will ultimately prove the book’s worth. Furthermore, in a wide-ranging volume
such as this, readers with different specialisms will, naturally, prefer
different articles. This should not be interpreted as negativity. This volume
certainly deserves to be on the bookshelves of all who claim an interest in
Irish prehistory and I know that George was thrilled to receive it.
Alex Gibson
University of Bradford
Review Submitted: July 2005
The views expressed in
this review are not necessarily those of the Society or the Reviews
Editor.
|