The moon and the bonfire. An investigation of three stone circles in north-east Scotland by Richard Bradley
Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland., 2005. 124 pages, 103 illustrations. ISBN0 903903 33 4 (£25)
Kilellan Farm, Ardnave, Islay. Excavations of a prehistoric to early medieval site 1954-1976 by Colin Burgess and others, Ed. Anna Ritchie.
Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. 2005. 200 pages, 100 illustrations. ISBN 0 903903 35 0. (£35)
These two volumes continue the excellent publication record of
the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. They are extremely well produced
volumes that will grace any bookshelf and both contain excellent if very
different data.
The Bradley volume, as the sub-title suggests, is the report on his excavations
at the recumbent stone circles of Tomnaverie (1999), Cothiemuir Wood and Aikey
Brae (2001). After setting the scene by discussing the origins and objectives
of the project and the problems with the dating of recumbent stone circles
Bradley proceeds to present the excavation reports of each site. These are
clearly written and excellently illustrated. The material results (finds etc)
are pretty sparse as might be expected, but the palaeoenvironmental resource is
maximised to great effect. The sequence of activity at the site as revealed by
stratigraphy and 14C dates is also described. And here is the meat of the
volume.
Subsoil burning and cremated bone predated the monumental sequence. The first
phase of the monument comprised a stone-built platform associated with Beaker
sherds was constructed around 2500-2400 cal BC to provide a level area on top
of the hill. The platform had radial internal divisions and a roughly polygonal
kerb and had been externally revetted by a rubble bank. The recumbent stone
circle had been inserted into this rubble revetment. There was further reuse of
the monument in the form of pyro-ritual activity c.1000 cal BC.
Interesting was the fact that the stone circle was the latest architectural
element thus challenging the conventional wisdom. However Bradley argues that
rather than stand-alone building phases, the elements of the monument may have
been designed as a single narrative not least because elements of the kerb and
the internal radial lines of the cairn seem to predict the position of the
uprights.
As mentioned above, the lateness of the stone circle in the site stratigraphy
was contrary to what one might have expected. Accordingly Cothiemuir Wood and
Aikey Brae were chosen for sampling to test whether the Tomnaverie sequence was
more widespread. It was. Fieldwalking projects by Tim Phillips suggest that the
sites were set away from the areas of contemporary occupation thus helping to
understand the landscape significance of the monuments.
Bradley then concludes with a thought provoking discussion of stone and timber
circle construction in Scotland, the importance of day and night time rituals
and the complex narratives that may have been involved at many sites. This
discussion will doubtless have far reaching effects.
Whereas Bradley’s volume reports on modern excavations undertaken less than 4
years prior to their publication, the Ardnave report describes excavations
undertaken as many decades before final publication. It even seems to show in
the cover photographs on the dust jackets: that of Kilellan Farm seems rather
faded in comparison to the vibrant colour at Tomnaverie. This said, Kilellan
Farm is an important site and Anna Ritchie must be congratulated on the superb
job she has done in pulling together the various archives which were, needless
to say, of varying quality and completeness. Indeed all the specialists have
dealt with this problem admirably. Ritchie describes the excavations herself
providing an introduction to the three different grid systems and the overall
site stratigraphy and context concordance. The results are then discussed in
chronological order from Mesolithic to medieval. The majority of this
description is, naturally, devoted to the Bronze Age midden and the tantalising
structural features that it preserved, and the later prehistoric souterrain.
Like The Moon and the Bonfire, this section is extremely well illustrated with
well-chosen informative photographs and line drawings which help illuminate the
complexities of the text.
Specialist contributions follow: the pottery, and especially the rich Early
Bronze Age assemblage, by Rosemary Cowie, the struck lithics by Alan Saville,
the other stone by Ann Clarke and other finds by Anna Ritchie. These sections,
and again the excellent illustrations, further confirm the importance of the
site and the wealth of material produced. Cowie’s pottery report is exemplary
and she puts to rest some old misconceptions such as the Beaker presence on the
site (originally identified by Colin Burgess and myself on tenuous evidence and
in a dusty Newcastle basement!).
The environmental reports (including snails by the late John Evans) comprise
only 22 of the 200 pages. The reports are well done on the evidence that
survives but given the overwhelming presence of dark ‘organic’ layers on the
majority of the photographs, one cannot help but think that here is an
opportunity missed (by the excavators not the specialists). Similarly,
radiocarbon dates are few no doubt a result of the shoe-string budgets of the
early excavations and Burgess’s scepticism of 14C dates at the time (a
scepticism borne out by the subsequent re-assessment of many dates, and the
recognition of laboratory errors (BM) and the old wood effect).
These volumes not only present a wealth of important archaeological data for
anyone interested in Scottish prehistory, but also highlight the differences
between well-constructed and funded programmes of research and lengthy ad hoc
poorly funded campaigns. They also demonstrate the benefit of speedy
publication as opposed to lengthy delays offering opportunity for the archive
to deteriorate making reconciliation of material and contexts difficult. Both
Bradley and Ritchie are to be congratulated. The former for his speedy and
thought provoking publication, the latter for struggling valiantly with a
variable archive, for bringing 20 years’ worth of important excavation to
fruition and finally rendering the old interims redundant.
Alex Gibson
University of Bradford
Review Submitted: June 2005
The views expressed in
this review are not necessarily those of the Society or the Reviews
Editor.
|