Life
on a Neolithic Site: Bylany - A Situational Analysis of Artefacts by
Ivan Pavlu
Prague: Institute of Archaeology. 2000. 340
pages, 17 photographs, 3 maps. ISBN 80-86124-24-X.
Bylany is one of a mosaic of Neolithic sites located virtually throughout
all of temperate Europe, and is representative of a collective which
is crucial to understanding the Neolithisation of Europe. This volume
comes at a time when this subject has yet again sparked the interest
of scholars, many of which seem to be either attempting syntheses of
Linienbandkeramik (LBK) emergence, or experimenting with various methodologies
and interpretive techniques in order to arrive at the most comprehensive
analysis of this phenomena.
Bylany is the largest Neolithic site studied in Bohemia to date. Initial
research at the site was focused on pioneering efforts to develop a
descriptive codex largely based on field documentation and descriptions
of more than 100, 000 ceramic artefacts from on-site house complexes.
This in turn served as the basis for the development of a chronology,
which with minor modifications over the years, remains accurate to the
present day. Since the first test pit was sunk in 1956, a continual
series of papers and publications, based on fieldwork and excavation
at the site, has been in press but at times difficult to access in the
Czech Republic, particularly during the Communist regime. The consequent
volume of information, data and interpretation that has been generated
by this site, and comprehensively presented within this volume, has
few parallels elsewhere in Europe. Virtually anything and everything
that may be of interest to a scholar of the LBK has been included, from
stone tools to housing structures. Furthermore, the author's insightful
use of situational analyses of the artefacts yields both surprising
interpretations, as well as observations not often considered.
The author begins by arranging attributes into a frame of questions
and problems. He then defines a matrix of nine areas of situational
analysis using physical existence, subjective experience and theoretical
process. Each category is then in turn used to organize questions regarding
different aspects of the artefacts. Since the physical features of artefacts
are primarily characterized by individual finds, the answers to other
questions require an analysis of the structure of artefacts within specific
contexts. Similar procedures are used for individual artefact types
(including flaked stone tools, polished stone tools, querns, pottery
decoration, housing structures and the settlement area), starting with
the basics of size and shape, leading up to design attributes, and concluding
with the symbolic attributes of style. Attributes are further quantified
within the context used. Simple statistical methods such as frequency
distributions, correlations between attributes and frequency tables
are used for this process of quantification. These tables further involve
correspondence analysis, deemed as the most suitable multi-statistical
method by the author. The vast majority of interpretations within this
volume are based on the results of such analyses.
Details of the individual situational analyses conducted, are described
in detail in the introduction to every chapter. To assist in the comprehension
of the reader, the text of every chapter is fully supplemented with
illustrations of schematic diagrams, tables and graphs, thereby making
the text accessible to readers without a profound understanding of statistical
reasoning.
Each artefact is discussed in its own chapter, and is evaluated in minute
detail. The fist chapter involves flaked stone tools. The usual data
is given, such as tool classification, blades versus flakes, raw materials
and their sources, and so on. However the remainder of the chapter explores
issues such as the identification of activities within households, implement
function, the gender and age of household members, the formation and
preservation of cultural tradition, and many other interesting considerations,
each of which is based on interpretations of the flaked stone industry.
In a similar manner and with similar considerations, the following chapter
is dedicated to the polished stone tool industry. Once again the usual
information is presented: classification of adzes/ axes, characteristics
of size, raw materials and their sources, use wear, quality and much
more besides. The remainder of the chapter however, involves interpretive
conclusions regarding kinship/ work groups, information and communication,
as it can be derived from the understanding of the polished stone tool
industry.
The following chapter comprises a detailed description and analysis
of mill stones excavated at the site. Data regarding the measurement
of upper and lower stones, their chronological variability, raw materials
and sources are all included. A sample of the interpretations found
in the chapter includes: the subsistence system, division of labour,
and an index of age of women in the household.
The next chapter involves pottery excavated from the site. This artefact
type is always difficult to represent since the variety of information
and interpretation can lead to volumes upon volumes of data. Nevertheless
the author has concisely presented data involving basic vessel characteristics
including: the ratios of principal forms, wall thickness, height/weight,
rim angle, knobs/handles, pedestals/feet, temper, firing and virtually
every characteristic that can be measured on a ceramic vessel. This
is followed by various interpretations that are sure to peak the curiosity
of all scholars of the Neolithic: the skill required to produce different
vessels, their function (short/long term storage, for serving food,
to hold water etc.), as indicators of household activities, as a sign
of prestige/ status, to sample but a few.
Due its complexity in both description and analysis, pottery decoration
has been given its own chapter. As before the chapter begins with the
presentation of basic data: the Bylany codex used to describe pottery
decoration (technical, incised, and relief decoration, red slip, painting,
motifs), fineware versus coarseware, frequency, etc. Interpretation
of this media leads the author to an exploration of "pottery sociology,"
in other words, "reflections on the possible relationships between
primary design motifs and the genealogy of the inhabitants at Bylany"
(p. 167). The content of the remainder of the chapter is sure to spark
the interest of all scholars of the LBK.
Housing structures are the subject of the following chapter. As with
the other chapters, the data is presented first. In this case the author
cites the house classifications, ground plans, and the interior sections.
A vast range of interpretations are then offered, of which the construction
materials and their volume, as well as interpretations of activities
in different sections, are only a small sample.
The final chapter of this volume includes interpretations of Bylany
as a settlement area. The temporal dynamics of asynchronic/ synchronic
house clusters, space outside the houses, houses and their rebuilding,
are a mere example of the considerations evaluated in this chapter.
There is no doubt that this volume must be on the shelf of every scholar
interested in the Neolithisation of temperate Europe. The above paragraphs
represent only a small fraction of the information that is actually
available within this book. It is rare to find such a vast source of
data and interpretation in one volume. Scholars everywhere are sure
to be inspired by this author's approach to seeking answers to questions
regarding the LBK and the onset of the Neolithic in Europe.
Alena Lukes
Department of Archaeology and Prehistory
University of Sheffield
Review Submitted: July 2002
The views expressed in this review are not necessarily
those of the Society or the Reviews Editor.
|