The Virtuous Scholar: Cleopatra seduced through intellectual prowess not physical beauty, says new book
23 February 2005
The modern perception of the legendary Egyptian Queen Cleopatra as a beautiful and manipulative diva is opposed by a new study that suggests that the real Cleopatra was in fact far more respected for her intellectual prowess than for her physical beauty.
The Arabic sources newly uncovered by Dr El Daly often refer to Cleopatra as 'The Virtuous Scholar', and cite scientific books written by her as the definitive works in their field. These sources focus on her many talents but make not one reference to sexuality or seductive power, instead admiring her scientific knowledge as a scholar, and her administrative ability.
"One remarkable omission from all the medieval Arabic sources that I have studied is any reference to Cleopatra's seductive physical beauty," writes Dr El Daly. "This absence perhaps emphasises that the fascination on the part of the Arab writers was with the conducts and achievements of the Queen rather than with her appearance. To judge from her appearance on her coins, she was not a beautiful woman in any conventional sense."
Dr El Daly continues: "The most interesting aspect of her image is that of a scholar who made significant contributions in the fields of alchemy, medicine and mathematics. She is shown conducting courtly seminars attended by scientists from different fields, at which she contributed to the discussions as a polymathic scientist."
In the words of the traveller and historian Al-Masudi (d 956): "She was a sage, a philosopher, who elevated the ranks of scholars and enjoyed their company. She also wrote books on medicine, charms and cosmetics in addition to many other books ascribed to her which are known to those who practice medicine."
The book examines a hitherto neglected period in the study of Egyptology, from the Moslem annexation of Egypt in the 7th Century CE until the Ottoman conquest in the 16th century. The commonly held view among European scholars was that there was no body of knowledge of Ancient Egypt, outside the context of European literature, from the Classical to the Enlightenment periods.
As well as suggesting a reinterpretation of Cleopatra, 'Egyptology: The Missing Millennium' examines how the medieval Arab scholars portrayed Ancient Egypt as the land of wisdom and science. The Arab sources attributed to pre-Islamic Egyptian scientists many scientific innovations - Mirabilia - including the 'early warning system' burning mirror at the top of the Alexandria lighthouse which guided ships into harbour, an automatic public clock that sounded every hour, and mechanical devices such as water-clocks and water wheels.
"It is quite clear that the study by medieval Egyptians and Arabs, its language, religion, monuments and general history, flourished long before the earliest European Renaissance contact," writes Dr El Daly. "Contrary to the prevailing view that Moslems, Arabs and Egyptians had no interest in Ancient Egypt, the sources show not only a keen interest, but also serious scholarship that seeks to understand and benefit from the study of Ancient Egypt."
Notes for Editors
1. 'Egyptology: The Missing Millennium. Ancient Egypt in Medieval Arabic Writings' is published by UCL Press on Wednesday 25 February 2005 . For review copies please contact Helen Guthrie at Cavendish Press on 0207 278 8000.
2. For more information, or to obtain images, please contact Dominique Fourniol in the UCL Media Relations Office on 0207 679 9728 or firstname.lastname@example.org .