The Panopticon

TBC

The panopticon penitentiary, from the Greek παν- ('all') and -οπτικος ('seeing') was based upon an idea of Jeremy's younger brother, Samuel, who, while working in Russia for Prince Potemkin, hit upon the 'central inspection principle', which would facilitate the training and supervision of unskilled workers by experienced craftsmen.

Jeremy came to adapt this principle for his proposed prison, an 'Inspection House' envisaged as a circular building, with the prisoners' cells arranged around the outer wall and the central point dominated by an inspection tower.

UC 119, f. 120: plan of the panopticon prison

From this building, the prison's inspector could look into the cells at any time—and even be able to speak to the prisoners in their cells via an elaborate network of 'conversation tubes'—though the inmates themselves would never be able to see the inspector.

Assuming that the omnipotent governor was always watching them, Bentham expected that this 'new mode of obtaining power of mind over mind, in a quantity hitherto without example' would ensure that the prisoners modify their behaviour and work hard in order to avoid chastisement and punishment.

The idea of constant, overbearing surveillance is certainly unsettling, but the panopticon and its central inspection principle would, Bentham argued, have multifarious benefits:

'Morals reformed-health preserved-industry invigorated-instruction diffused-public burthens lightened-Economy seated, as it were, upon a rock-the gordian knot of the Poor-Laws not cut, but untied-all by a simple idea in Architecture!'

Panopticon drawings and manuscripts

Bentham commissioned the architect Willey Reveley to make plans and drawings for the Panopticon. Box 119 of the Bentham Papers, in the care of UCL Library Special Collections, contains these items as well as many of Bentham's writings on the Panopticon. Digitised versions of the manuscripts are available at Transcribe Bentham, and interested parties are invited to assist the Bentham Project by transcribing them.

Panopticon Pandemonium: bringing to life Bentham's unrealised prison

Panopticon Pandemonium is a computer game which brings to life the complexities and ambiguities of Bentham's prison scheme. It sees the construction—virtually—of a working panopticon for the first time. The player, assisted by Bentham himself, acts as governor of the prison and has to balance economies of the social benefits of Bentham's vision-happiness, rehabilitation, work-against the functions of discipline, punishment, and surveillance, while also ensuring that their panopticon is orderly and profitable.

Were any Panopticons built?

The following prisons, some of which no longer exist, reflect Bentham's ideas for the Panopticon. However, none conform precisely to the detailed drawings or to Bentham's principles of management—the key to which was unobserved inspection. One lasting legacy of Bentham's plan to build and manage a panopticon prison is Tate Britain, the art gallery that stands on the banks of the River Thames on the site bought by Bentham for his prison.

That its design is 'panoptic' is a claim made for many prisons such as Kilmainham Gaol, Dublin, which was based on the very influential design of Pentonville Prison, built in London in 1842.

Buildings designed for other purposes have also been called panopticons and yet other buildings resemble the Panopticon design by virtue of their circular plan.

Europe
Great Britain, Edinburgh panopticon described in The Collected Works of Jeremy Bentham: Correspondence Volume 4: October 1788 to December 1793, ed. Alexander Taylor Milne (The Athlone Press, 1981).

Italy, Siena. The Padiglione Conolly was part of the now decommissioned Psychiatric Hospital San Niccolo. Designed by Francesco Azzurri, the Padiglione opened in 1876. Find out more about the Padiglione in a short article by Dr. Alessandro Spina and Dr. Andrea Friscelli (PDF).

Italy, Santo Stefano. (80 miles south of Rome, and 40 miles offshore in the Tyrrhenian Sea, in the Pontine Archipelago). A panopticon style prison was established on this island in 1795. It closed in 1965.

Portugal, Security Pavilion, Museum Infirmary, the museum of the Hospital Miguel Bombarda in Lisbon. The Security Pavilion (1892-1896) was designed to be a forensic prison infirmary for patients from the penitentiary, or other patients considered dangerous, and should not be confused with a typical psychiatric ward from the period. It functioned from 1896 to 2000, when it was closed. In 2001 it was declared a monument of public interest by IPPAR (Instituto Português do Património Arquitectónico).

Netherlands
More information will be available shortly on three panopticons which have recently been renovated by the Dutch government, including two late nineteenth century panopticons in Arnhem and Breda (Architect, J.F. Metzelaar).

Lelystad Prison built in 1995. Architect J.C. Putter of Van Meer en Putter Architecten. The building consists of two domes with central guard stations.

Haarlem, by son of Metzelaar. Early 20th century.

Russia, St Petersburg. Designed and supervised by Samuel Bentham, the St Petersburg panopticon was a school rather than a prison. The Panopticon School of Arts, begun in 1806, was destroyed by fire in 1818. The Russian State Naval Archive has given permission for the reproduction of an architectural drawing (1810) of the building.

Spain, Mataró, panopticon established 1863 (referred to in "Legislator of the World": Writings on Codification, Law, and Education, eds. Philip Scholfield and Jonathan Harris (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1998, p. xxvii, n. 10).

Switzerland, Geneva. A prison modelled on the panopticon was built in 1825 and demolished in 1862. See Robert Roth, Pratiques pénitentiaires et théorie sociale. l'exemple de la prison de Genève (1825–1862), Genèva: Librairie Droz, 1981.

North America
Rahway Prison, New Jersey, USA.
Stateville Penitentiary, Illinois, USA.

Central America
Isle of Pines, Cuba, built 1932.

South America
The Bogota 'Panoptico', Columbia.

South Africa
The Old Provost now a part of the Albany Museum, Grahamstown, Cape province, South Africa.

Australia
The Round House Fremantle. An image of the sign at the Round House states that the architect Henry Willey Revely 'may have been influenced by Jeremy Bentham's plan for the model prison'. This is particularly interesting in view of the fact that H.W. Reveley (1788–1875) was the son of Willey Reveley (d. 1799), the architect who drew up the original plans for the Panopticon in London.

Further reading