XClose

Institute of Brand and Innovation Law

Home
Menu

Rethinking distinctiveness of shape trade marks

By Professor Ilanah Fhima

IPQ cover

23 August 2024

Publication details

Ilanah Fhima, 'Rethinking distinctiveness of shape trade marks' [2024] I.P.Q. 79.

Abstract

Consumers recognise goods by their shape as well as by how they are labelled. However, shape marks potentially grant monopoly rights in the shape of goods, which can result in functional characteristics falling into the hands of a single undertaking. The Court of Justice of the European Union (EU) adopts a cautious approach to registering shape marks. Despite the competitive risk such marks pose, the Court’s reasoning has always been based on arguments that consumers will not generally view shapes of goods as indicative of origin, and not on the need to keep shape marks free for others to use. This article draws on psycholinguistics to argue that the Court’s approach to consumer perception is justified. However, it draws on object recognition theory which posits that there is a finite number of basic components from which shapes can be composed, suggesting that there is a competitive risk to registering shape marks which should be recognised in how the grounds for the refusal of registration are applied to shape marks.