Skip to main content
Navigate back to homepage
Open search bar.
Open main navigation menu

Main navigation

  • Study
    UCL Portico statue
    Study at UCL

    Being a student at UCL is about so much more than just acquiring knowledge. Studying here gives you the opportunity to realise your potential as an individual, and the skills and tools to thrive.

    • Undergraduate courses
    • Graduate courses
    • Short courses
    • Study abroad
    • Centre for Languages & International Education
  • Research
    Tree-of-Life-MehmetDavrandi-UCL-EastmanDentalInstitute-042_2017-18-800x500-withborder (1)
    Research at UCL

    Find out more about what makes UCL research world-leading, how to access UCL expertise, and teams in the Office of the Vice-Provost (Research, Innovation and Global Engagement).

    • Engage with us
    • Explore our Research
    • Initiatives and networks
    • Research news
  • Engage
    UCL Print room
    Engage with UCL

    Discover the many ways you can connect with UCL, and how we work with industry, government and not-for-profit organisations to tackle tough challenges.

    • Alumni
    • Business partnerships and collaboration
    • Global engagement
    • News and Media relations
    • Public Policy
    • Schools and priority groups
    • Visit us
  • About
    UCL welcome quad
    About UCL

    Founded in 1826 in the heart of London, UCL is London's leading multidisciplinary university, with more than 16,000 staff and 50,000 students from 150 different countries.

    • Who we are
    • Faculties
    • Governance
    • President and Provost
    • Strategy

The role and effectiveness of kitemarks in preventing online fraud

Breadcrumb trail

Research summary

The migration of so many aspects of our lives to digital environments creates numerous opportunities for new fraudulent schemes. Scammers abuse the trust of online users and exploit the difficulty of distinguishing genuine online accounts, websites, services and products from fake ones. To keep people safe online a number of private as well as government run schemes are introducing ‘kitemarks’ – that is, labels or seals – that certify that a particular online service is safe, often on the basis of verification by a trusted third party (Remotti et al, 2012). For example, the British Standards Institution (BSI) award various kitemarks to certify that products and services, such as digital applications (or “apps”) and digital banking are secure (BSI 2023). 

One example is Trustpilot. This is a consumer review website where consumers can leave reviews for products, services and companies (Trustpilot 2023a). The aim of Trustpilot is to help consumers shop with confidence and to help companies improve their business. With nearly 1 million reviews posted each month, the website provides a way for the public to check if websites are likely to be legitimate. Moreover, Trustpilot provides businesses with a rating badge that they can post on their own website as a way to communicate trust, which users can click on this to verify its authenticity (Trustpilot 2023b). 

However, little is known about user awareness of, and interactions with, such kitemarks and their effectiveness in preventing fraud. Research that specifically addresses the utility of kitemarks for fraud prevention or their vulnerability to fraudulent exploitation is still limited. In terms of user awareness of kitemarks, during the pandemic we conducted a survey (with Neighbourhood Watch) to understand people’s day-to-day online security behaviour, including their knowledge and use of UK TrustPilot and the MHRA logo (Johnson & Nikolovska 2020). Based on answers from nearly 15K respondents, we found that only 10% were aware of the MHRA logo. Our results suggest that awareness of these schemes is limited, and even more so, users do not tend to take advantage of the opportunity to click on existing kitemarks to verify their validity. This is concerning as simply relying on logo information may be unsafe, as anyone can fake such a logo. 

This project will seek to further identify kitemark schemes used in the UK and elsewhere and examine people’s behaviours and perceptions in relation to them. It will aim to evaluate users’ awareness of kitemark schemes and their implications for online security. We will also examine whether there are flaws in their implementation. For example, in the case of Trustpilot, we note that an offender could register a similarly named website to mislead consumers. 

Lead Investigator(s)
  • Prof Shane Johnson, UCL Security and Crime Science 
  • Dr Lorenzo Pasculli, UCL Security and Crime Science 
  • Dr Manja Nikolovska, UCL Security and Crime Science  
Outputs 

More from UCL Engineering...

Engineering Foundation Year
UCL East Marshgate building at dusk

Programme Spotlight

Engineering Foundation Year

We'll help you to gain new knowledge, learn academic and study skills, and develop your confidence levels so you'll have what it takes to transform your life.

Inaugural Lectures
Farhaneen Mazlan delivering a talk at UCL

Event series

Inaugural Lectures

An opportunity to explore ground-breaking research that is shaping the future and transforming the world.

Disruptive Thinkers Video Series
Dr Claire Walsh looking at a human organ in an imaging facility

Watch Now

Disruptive Thinkers Video Series

From making cities more inclusive to using fibre optics in innovative medical procedures, explore the disruptive thinking taking place across UCL Engineering.

UCL footer

Visit

  • Bloomsbury Theatre and Studio
  • Library, Museums and Collections
  • UCL Maps
  • UCL Shop
  • Contact UCL

Students

  • Accommodation
  • Current Students
  • Moodle
  • Students' Union

Staff

  • Inside UCL
  • Staff Intranet
  • Work at UCL
  • Human Resources

UCL social media menu

  • Link to Soundcloud
  • Link to Flickr
  • Link to TikTok
  • Link to Youtube
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to Twitter

University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT

Tel: +44 (0) 20 7679 2000

© 2025 UCL

Essential

  • Disclaimer
  • Freedom of Information
  • Accessibility
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • Slavery statement
  • Log in