Skip to site navigation

Lords Reform Votes

March 2007

Motion Text For Against Majority
1
That this house is of the opinion that a reformed House of Lords should be fully appointed 361
121
240
2
That this house is of the opinion that a reformed house of lords should be composed of 20 per cent elected members and 80 per cent appointed members Rejected without division    
3
That this house is of the opinion that a reformed house of lords should be composed of 40 per cent elected members and 60 per cent appointed members Rejected without division    
4
That this house is of the opinion that a reformed house of lords should be composed of 50 per cent elected members and 50 per cent appointed members 46
410* -364
5
That this house is of the opinion that a reformed house of lords should be composed of 60 per cent elected members and 40 per cent appointed members 45
393* -348
6
That this house is of the opinion that a reformed house of lords should be composed of 80 per cent elected members and 20 per cent appointed members 114
336
-222
7 That this house is of the opinion that a reformed House of Lords should be fully elected 
122 326 -204

*As noted in the House of Lords minutes, the tellers reported one fewer vote than this (and so this is recorded in Hansard). However, the clerks recorded this number of names (which are listed in Hansard).


Parliament Homepage

NEWS


Read more Unit News here >

BLOG

What the Queen said – and what she didn’t say

Thu, 28 May 2015 12:35:34 +0000

Following yesterday’s Queen’s Speech, Robert Hazell considers the constitutional issues that featured, as well as those which were notable in their absence. There were few surprises in the Queen’s Speech announcing the new government’s legislative programme. Like his admired predecessor Tony Blair, David Cameron knows that the public have little interest in constitutional issues, so […]

Read more...

Routes to EVEL: The challenges facing Chris Grayling in introducing English votes on English laws

Tue, 26 May 2015 10:15:42 +0000

With the Queen’s Speech due tomorrow, we continue our series of blogs about devolution and its consequences, drawing on the Unit’s latest report Devolution and the Future of the Union. Here Robert Hazell analyses the commitment to English votes on English laws, looking first at its history, and then at its prospects. Cynics might assume […]

Read more...

Can David Cameron call a second election? How does that fit with the Fixed Term Parliaments Act?

Fri, 22 May 2015 10:00:34 +0000

Robert Hazell outlines how the Fixed Term Parliaments Act restricts the new government from calling a second election. He writes that if Cameron wanted to take a gamble to boost his slender majority, he would have to work within the confines of the Act given the likely complexities of any attempt to repeal it. This […]

Read more...
Meg Russell's new book, The Contemporary House of Lords:
Lords book cover - png file

Projects 

CONSULTANCY

The Constitution Unit

Page last modified on 09 feb 11 17:20

Footer menu