Mesolithic Lives in Scotland by Graeme Warren
Tempus. 2005. 160 pages, 62 b/w illustrations, 24 plates. ISBN 0-7524-3448-9 (£17.99)
This slim but attractively-presented volume sets out to present an account of
the lives of Scotland’s earliest inhabitants that is accessible to
undergraduates and to those with a general interest in archaeology. Much effort
is spent in explaining complicated processes (such as sea-level change) and in
demystifying specialist terminology (principally that relating to lithic
studies); and much of the book is taken up with exploring the various
approaches that have been, and could be, used to understand Scottish Mesolithic
people’s lives.
The book is organised into seven thematic chapters, dealing respectively with
chronology; the changing landscape; the nature and importance of, and
interaction with, the forest; the use of resources (in general, and in terms of
the use of learned skills); landscapes and taskscapes; and population and
communities. An introductory section sets out some basic definitions, reviews
past approaches and sets out the author’s stall with regard to his own approach
(which seeks to ‘humanise’ the Mesolithic); and an Epilogue returns to a
discussion of that approach. Each chapter offers a helpful guide to further
reading, complete with a commentary on the publications in question; and all
sections except the Epilogue employ the Socratic device of ‘An Interjection’,
in which the author imagines and addresses the kind of questions that the
reader might raise.
The book is very much of its time, in terms of one particular current approach
to the British and Irish Mesolithic, in its aim of getting close to its
subjects through focusing on how they lived their lives and made sense of the
world around them. This ‘empathetic’ approach, with its emphasis on materiality
and phenomenology, on gender, identity and perception, can be seen, for
instance, in contributions such as Steven Mithen’s ‘The “Mesolithic Experience”
in Scotland’ (in Mesolithic Scotland and its Neighbours (ed. A.
Saville, 2004, Society of Antiquaries of Scotland), and in the work of Chantal
Conneller, Nyree Finlay, Tim Ingold and Lesley McFadyen. Similarly, the use of
Socratic dialogue and of a personalised, auto-critical style – and indeed of
the evocative photos of trees, the sea, a woodland path etc. – is very much in
line with this kind of archaeological approach (cf. the work of Barbara Bender,
Mark Edmonds, Chris Tilley etc.). The desire to achieve an intimate
understanding of past people as human beings is, of course, a laudable aim, and
Warren is right to praise the attempts of researchers such as Nyree Finlay in
trying to squeeze as much information (about gendered behaviour, for example)
from an avowedly difficult set of data. He is also wise to use terms such as
‘materiality’ sparingly, and to distance himself from the wackier expressions
of this ‘touchy-feely’ approach which have done so much to perpetuate the
glacial stand-offs between different sects within the church of Mesolithic
archaeology.
How well does Warren succeed in bringing us closer to understanding what made
Scotland’s earliest inhabitants tick – and in particular, in helping
non-specialists on this quest?
In explaining complex processes such as environmental and sea-level change, his
text is admirably clear and well illustrated – even if his exposition of lithic
terms could have benefited from a few more definitions and explanations (e.g.
of ‘blunting’, and of the various functions of retouch). His exploration about
how people are likely to have related to the forest is right in showcasing this
aspect of Mesolithic life. His accounts of the various problems facing any
interpretative approach to the Mesolithic, and of the drawbacks of many
previous attempts, is right and proper. Factual errors are mercifully few; last
time I looked, Cornwall was not ‘over 500 km away’ from Hampshire (p. 139).
This book is set to grace many an undergraduate course in British prehistory.
Its guides to ‘Further Reading’ provide an important steer towards the sources
of ‘nuts and bolts’ information. And its inclusion of brief summary ‘Reviews’
in many of the chapters reflects the author’s understanding of how
undergraduate readers’ minds operate!
Inevitably, comparisons will be made with Caroline Wickham-Jones’ book on the
same subject, directed at a similar audience, published 15 years ago (Scotland’s
First Settlers: Batsford/Historic Scotland). Warren’s book is more up
to date, if slightly less lavishly illustrated; and so much of its author’s
energy is spent earnestly trying to do the right thing by his subjects – in
explaining what we can’t know for sure, and in debating the rights and wrongs
of specific approaches –that, at some points, it reads more like a journey
through the author’s own quest for enlightenment than a guide for the
uninitiated. This is, perhaps, a harsh judgement on what is an honest appraisal
of a frankly challenging subject, and a sincere attempt to help readers get to
grips with the evidence. It demonstrates how very hard it is to construct a
straightforward yet detailed and profound narrative of the lives of Scotland’s
earliest inhabitants.
The sales, and use, of this book will eventually determine whether it succeeds
in its aim. For this reviewer, there are aspects of its style that are not to
her taste (such as the Interjections, which grate slightly); and, while she
understands the author’s reasons for body-swerving the tricky subject of what
happened to Scotland’s foragers once agriculture came on the scene, it’s a
shame that this topic didn’t get a bit more of an airing, to round off the
account.
But clearly this book is a thoughtful, and indeed a caring, account, and it
will be interesting to see how and whether its author’s views change as his
quest continues over the coming decades.
Alison Sheridan
National Museums of Scotland
Review Submitted: June 2006
The views expressed in
this review are not necessarily those of the Society or the Reviews
Editor.
|