Bronzefunde aus Rumänien II, (ed) Tudor Soroceanu
Biblioteca Muzeului Bistrita, Seria Historica 11; Accent, Cluj-Napoca, 2005; 501 pages, numerous illustrations, text in German and Romanian; ISBN 973-8445-81-7 (price not known)
This volume contains contributions to the publication and interpretation of
Late Bronze Age and Early Iron Age metalwork finds from Romania in their
European context. There are three by the editor (who is based in Berlin) and
fourteen others by colleagues from Romania, Germany and Ukraine. Texts are in
German or Romanian language - a few bilingual, with abstracts in various
languages, sometimes including French though excluding English. This does not
mean, however, that the authors overlook British finds or literature.
Dr Soroceanu’s first article is a historical assessment of the contribution to
the study of prehistoric metallurgy of an article published in 1913 (pp 15-46).
His second deals with deposition of Late Bronze Age hoards of metal vessels (pp
387-428). This is based on a selective but wide-ranging catalogue that includes
the recent find from Tamlaght in Ireland, Hattenknowe in Scotland, Broom in
England and the important Rosnoën hoard with a cauldron from Saint-Ygeaux in
Brittany. Four main patterns of deposition are distinguished and such aspects
as the numbers of vessels and the presence of any structure around the hoard
are discussed to identify the main elements for the interpretation of these
deposits. This will be a valuable reference for discussion of finds new and
old.
Dr Soroceanu is compiling the Prähistorische Bronzefunde volume on
metal vessels from Romania and his third paper reconsiders the pair of Kurd
buckets from Brâncovenesti in Translyvania (pp 429-76). Objects like these tend
to stay undisturbed in their museum cases and rarely receive such thorough
study. A detailed discussion concludes that the buckets are not local products
of early Urnfield date, but instead late Urnfield/early Hallstatt vessels of
east-Alpine origin; this allows other Romanian finds to be attributed to the
same period. As the author points out (p 461 n 257) his redating of
Brâncovenesti - known by its Hungarian name of Marosvécs in some British
publications - could have implications for the chronology of insular buckets
and we hope for publication during 2006 of Sabine Gerloff’s PBF volume
on the British vessels for an up-to-date discussion of their origin. The volume
concludes with a short metallurgical study of the Brâncovenesti buckets (pp
477-85).
Also of general interest is an article on the socketed hammers from Romania (pp
343-86) with a catalogue of sixty-five, including a few moulds and several
examples of socketed axes reused as hammers. Other contributions deal with
finds of hoards, metalworking material or collections of metalwork from
Romania. Two German contributions, by Alix Hänsel and Svend Hansen, are simply
Romanian translations of articles published elsewhere in German, but a third by
Carola Metzner-Nebelsick (pp 317-42) summarises in Romanian (without an
abstract in any language) her German publications on the chronological and
cultural significance of Late Bronze and Early Iron Age hoards from Romania,
including so-called ‘Thraco-Cimmerian’ material.
The first volume of Bronzefunde aus Rumänien was published in 1995 (T
Soroceanu, ed, Bronzefunde aus Rumänien, Berlin, Volker Spiess,
Prähistorische Archäologie in Südosteuropa 10) along similar lines, containing
articles on about a dozen hoards or other finds and another by the editor on
deposition of hoards and swords (pp 15-80). An index of the finds in both
volumes appears in volume II (pp 487-500).
Brendan O’Connor,
Edinburgh
Review Submitted: January 2006
The views expressed in
this review are not necessarily those of the Society or the Reviews
Editor.
|