UCL SPP hosts Nick Clegg on 'How to Stop Brexit' and Richard Aikens / Robert Tombs in support of Brexit.
21 February 2018
The School of Public Policy at UCL is proud to have hosted two big events on Brexit this term, one for and one against.
On Thursday 25 January Sir Nick Clegg gave a talk on ‘How to stop Brexit’, publicising his book with that title. To a packed audience of 1000 students he argued that it was not too late for the UK to change its course, and quoted David Davis saying ‘If a democracy cannot change its mind, it ceases to be a democracy’. Younger people had voted predominantly to remain in the EU, but if they wanted that to happen, they would need to mobilise: in his book, he set out a five point checklist on how to put pressure on the Labour Party and Conservative Party .
Nick Clegg’s lecture's video can be viewed here.
In an equally packed lecture theatre on 22 February, Professor Robert Tombs and Sir Richard Aikens explained the historian’s and the lawyer’s case for Brexit. Robert Tombs (Professor of French history at Cambridge) said that the EU and the UK both stood at a historic juncture. President Macron had acknowledged that the EU faced an existential crisis, and had set out a bold vision in his Sorbonne speech for stronger EU control of finance, security, labour markets and more. It was an honest, coherent vision of a sovereign EU, but one which was likely to fail. But was this the kind of EU that the UK signed up for, or might want to rejoin? Because that was now the choice; the decision had been made to leave, in the 2016 referendum, followed by the vote in Parliament to authorise the triggering of Article 50. If subsequently the UK wanted to rejoin, it might have to become a full member of the EU, including joining the euro; or accept becoming a satellite member of an increasingly federalised Europe. Moreover, this would risk causing a major constitutional and political crisis in Britain.
For a fuller text from Robert Tombs see here. For further writing by Professor Tombs, and other academic experts who support Brexit, see the website of the new organisation he has founded, Briefings for Brexit.
Sir Richard Aikens QC, former Court of Appeal judge, based his support for Brexit on a careful reading of the EU Treaties. The Treaties had created economic and monetary union, and the euro. Despite the rejection of the proposed EU constitution in referendums in 2005, the Treaties in effect created a constitution for the EU. But the peoples of Europe had never been properly asked if they wanted a federal Europe. The EU had increasingly wide competences, which the Commission was likely to extend further. For the EU to be accepted as legitimate, it had to become more democratic. The full text of Sir Richard’s opening talk and his analysis of the Treaties can be viewed here.
Prof Robert Hazell, convenor of the Policy Practice Seminars, said: “We were very pleased in January to welcome back Nick Clegg, and his lecture attracted huge interest. We also got an equally large audience on 22 February for Sir Richard Aikens and Sir Robert Tombs. Brexiteers are sometimes dismissed as uneducated and left behind. Richard Aikens is a leading lawyer; Robert Tombs a most distinguished historian. Between them explained the intellectual case for Brexit”
• View Nick Clegg's lecture here.
• In 2017, The Constitution Unit organised the Citizens’ Assembly on Brexit. This brought citizens together to engage in detailed, reflective and informed discussions about what the UK’s post-Brexit relations with the European Union should be. The Assembly’s recommendations for the form that Brexit should take are the fullest evidence currently existing of citizens’ considered and detailed opinions on this question.
• The Constitution Unit has established an Independent Commission on Referendums. The Commission is ongoing and is due to report in the summer of 2018.