Seeing the world differently
6 December 2010
- Research in Nature Neuroscience
- UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience
- The Wellcome Trust
- Coverage in the Scotsman
- Scientific American podcast
Scientists have shown for the first time that exactly how we see our environment depends on the size of the visual part of our brain.
We are all familiar with the idea that our thoughts and
emotions differ from one person to another, but most people assume that how we
perceive the visual world is usually very similar from person to person.
However, the primary visual cortex – the area at the back of the brain responsible
for processing what we see in the world around us – is known to differ in size by
up to three times from one individual to the next.
Now, researchers at the Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging at UCL (University College London) have shown for the first time that the size of this area affects how we perceive our environment. Their study is published online today in the journal Nature Neuroscience.
Dr D Samuel Schwarzkopf, Chen Song and Professor Geraint Rees showed a series of optical illusions to thirty healthy volunteers. These included the Ebbinghaus illusion, a well-known illusion in which two circles of the same size are each surrounded by circular 'petals'; one of the circles is surrounded by larger petals, the other by smaller petals. Most people will see the first circle as smaller than the second one
In a second optical illusion, the Ponzo illusion, the volunteers were shown two identically sized circles superimposed onto the image of a tunnel. In this illusion, the circle placed further back in the tunnel appears larger than that placed near the front.
By adapting these illusions, the researchers were able to show that individual volunteers saw the illusions differently. For example, some people saw a big (although illusory) difference in size between the two circles, but others barely saw any difference in apparent size.
Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), the researchers were also able to measure the surface area of the primary visual cortex in each volunteer. They found a great deal of variability in the size of this area..Surprisingly, there was a strong link between its size and the extent to which volunteers perceived the size illusion – the smaller the area, the more pronounced the visual illusion.
"Our work is the first to show that the size of part of a person's brain can predict how they perceive their visual environment," explains Dr Schwarzkopf.
"Optical illusions mystify and inspire our imagination, but in truth they show us that how we see the world is not necessarily physically accurate, but rather depends a lot on our brains. Illusions such as the ones we used influence how big something looks; that is, they can trick us into believing that two identical objects have different sizes.
"We have shown that precisely how big something appears to you depends on the size of a brain area that is necessary for vision. How much your brain tricks you depends on how much 'real estate' your brain has put aside for visual processing."
Image: The Ebbinghaus illusion, a well-known illusion in which
two circles of the same size are each surrounded by circular 'petals'; one of
the circles is surrounded by larger petals, the other by smaller petals. Most
people will see the first circle as smaller than the second one
together all UCL neuroscientists to unravel the mysteries of the nervous
system. They work across seven major themes to make fundamental
about brain function and behaviour, to teach and train the next
scientists and clinicians, and to transform our ability to diagnose and
and psychiatric disease.