Climate change won't reduce winter deaths
23 February 2014
Climate change is unlikely to reduce the UK’s excess winter death rate as previously thought.
A new study, published today in Nature Climate Change, debunks the widely held view that warmer winters will cut the number of deaths normally seen at the coldest time of year.
Analysing data from the past 60 years, researchers at UCL and the University of Exeter looked at how the winter death rate has changed over time, and what factors influenced it.
They found that from 1951 to 1971, the number of cold winter days was strongly linked to death rates, while from 1971 to 1991, both the number of cold days and flu activity were responsible for increased death rates. However, their analysis showed that from 1991 to 2011, flu activity alone was the main cause in year to year variation in winter mortality.
Lead researcher Dr Philip Staddon says: “We’ve shown that the number of cold days in a winter no longer explains its number of excess deaths. Instead, the main cause of year to year variation in winter mortality in recent decades has been flu.”
Climate change appears unlikely to lower winter death rates. Indeed, it may substantially increase them by driving extreme weather events and greater variation in winter temperatures. Action must be taken to prevent this happening.
Professor Hugh Montgomery (UCL Institute for Human Health & Performance)
The team suggest that this reduced link between the number of cold days and deaths in a winter can be explained by improvements in housing, health care, income and a greater awareness of the risks of the cold.
As climate change progresses, the UK is likely to experience increasing weather extremes, including a greater number of less predictable periods of extreme cold. The research highlights that, despite a generally warmer winter, a more volatile climate could actually lead to increased numbers of winter deaths associated with climate change, rather than fewer.
Dr Staddon believes the findings have important implications for policy: "Both policy makers and health professionals have, for some time, assumed that a potential benefit from climate change will be a reduction in deaths seen over winter. We’ve shown that this is unlikely to be the case. Efforts to combat winter mortality due to cold spells should not be lessened, and those against flu and flu-like illnesses should also be maintained.”
Co-author Professor Hugh Montgomery, Director of the UCL Institute for Human Health & Performance, says: “Climate change appears unlikely to lower winter death rates. Indeed, it may substantially increase them by driving extreme weather events and greater variation in winter temperatures. Action must be taken to prevent this happening.”
Co-author, Prof Michael Depledge of University of Exeter Medical School says: "Studies of the kind we have conducted provide information that is key for policymakers and politicians making plans to manage the impacts of climate change. We’re hopeful that the importance of this issue will be understood, so that matters of health and environmental security can be dealt with seriously and effectively.”
The research used data from the Office of National Statistics on so called ‘excess winter deaths’, a figure calculated by taking the number of deaths in winter (those in December to March) and subtracting the average number of deaths for the two adjoining non-winter periods (April to July of the current year and August to November of the previous year). Over the past decade excess winter deaths in England and Wales have ranged from ~25,000 to ~31,000, with the latter figure occurring in the winter of 2012-2013.
- Full paper in Nature Climate Change (£)
- Professor Hugh Montgomery's academic profile on Iris
- UCL Institute for Human Health & Performance
- University of Exeter
- London in the snow (Courtesy of Edvvc on Flickr)