UCL Laws News
2011-12 News
May 2012
Ioannis Lianos Speaks at St Petersburg International Legal Forum
Dr. Ioannis Lianos, Director of the Centre for Law, Economics and Society at UCL Laws and a Director at the Institute of Global Law and Mr Martin Adams, a UCL alumnus and associate at international law firm Kirkland & Ellis LLP in New York, were invited to speak at the 2nd St Petersburg International Legal Forum, held under the auspices of the Russian Presidency at the State Hermitage in St Petersburg on May 16-19 2012. The forum was opened by Russian Prime Minister D. Medvedev and included as main speakers, among others, the Lord Chancellor, Kenneth Clarke, US Attorney General, Eric Holder, and the Minister of Justice of the People's Republic of China, Wu Aiying.
Dr. Lianos contributed to the plenary session of the forum on the "Implementation of the Open Government Initiatives in the Legal System" discussing the European OpenGov experience. Other panellists in this session included the Minister of Justice of the Russian Federation and the Assistant Attorney General of the US Department of Justice. Mr Adams and Dr Lianos also contributed as speakers to the session on "Social Networks and Mobile Applications: Challenges and Opportunities for Legal Regulation", a forward looking discussion of the important challenges faced by a number of jurisdictions worldwide in the regulation of social media platforms (with regard to privacy, antitrust and network neutrality issues) but also of the important transformation of social relations that the emergence of these new technologies entails.
Beecroft Report on Employment Law Leaked
Dr Nicola Countouris of UCL Laws comments on labour regulation in the UK compared to other countries in the EU.
Catherine Redgwell Receives Funding for Climate Geoengineering Governance Project
Professor Catherine Redgwell of UCL Laws has been awarded £143,708 as co-investigator in a £1.3m two year research project on Climate Geoengineering Governance (CGG) funded by the ESRC and AHRC.
The CGG project will be led from the Institute for Science, Innovation and Society, University of Oxford, and will also involve the Institute for Science and Ethics at Oxford together with the Science and Technology Policy Research at the University of Sussex and UCL Faculty of Laws. Work is grouped around three sets of understandings required to inform decisions on geoengineering governance: framings of geoengineering; dilemmas of control of geoengineering technologies; and choosing governance and regulatory requirements. The project builds on the “Oxford Principles on Geoengineering Governance” (2009) which were endorsed by the House of Commons Select Committee on Science and Technology report on The Regulation of Geoengineering (House of Commons 2010) and also by the UK Government in its Response to the Select Committee report. Professors Redgwell (UCL Laws), Rayner and Savulescu (Oxford) were amongst the co-authors of the Principles and are leading researchers on this CGG project.
Real-world beaming: The risk of avatar and robot crime
In a recent article in BBC News magazine, Professor Mel Slater (UCL Computer Science), Professor Patrick Haggard (UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience) and Ray Purdy (UCL Laws) talk about beaming, and the ethical and legal issues raised by the technology.
Apr 2012
Cumberland Lodge 2012 Study Retreat for PhD Students
On 25-26 April, a group of over 20 students and Faculty members attended the fourth annual UCL Laws Research study retreat at Cumberland Lodge, Great Park, Windsor. The aim of the retreat is to foster the Faculty's research community by offering students the time and space to think about their research projects together, receiving peer feedback in an informal and supportive setting. The Cumberland Lodge retreat is open to all research students at UCL Laws, with priority given to those who are in the first year of their PhD programme. This year's Cumberland Lodge event was organised by members of the Research Studies Team. Participating students provided valuable input on the conference agenda and related activities. During the retreat, students held an 'ideas fair', a writing clinic, and a reading workshop, commenting upon short presentations from their peers as to current research in progress. Participants also had time to enjoy walks in the park and some extra-curricular activities.
Douglas Guilfoyle awarded British Academy Mid-Career Research Fellowship
Douglas Gulifoyle has been awarded a British Academy Mid-Career Research Fellowship for the 2012-13 academic year for his proposal entitled 'Governing the Oceans: The Law of the Sea and Contemporary Challenges'. These fellowships support "outstanding individual researchers and outstanding communicators who will promote public engagement and understanding of the humanities and social sciences."
Douglas's project will examine the emergence of new mechanisms of international cooperation and governance dealing with novel maritime security threats or challenges across a range of case studies. Such threats often involve a combination of weak states and asymmetrical non-state actors (i.e. organised groups able to cause great harm with limited resources). For example: illegal fishing thrives through states which do not regulate their vessels; piracy thrives in disordered Somalia; irregular migration by sea is exacerbated by state failure and porous borders. The overall argument will suggest that the key problem is not the law, but the weak ability of many States to exert their jurisdiction and the nature of new threats posed by non-State actors (especially transnational organised crime). The project will also explore whether the fragmented regime of international governance institutions dealing with the maritime domain may actually facilitate experimentation and adaptive responses to novel challenges.
Part of Douglas's public communication strategy for the project is to create a series of YouTube ‘screencasts’ (where a speech track is laid over slides, diagrams and images) to create an accessible introduction to both basic concepts in the law of the sea and case studies in specialist problems in maritime security.
UCL LLM Students Present ‘Law Without Walls’ Research in Miami
Three UCL LLM students recently travelled to Miami Law School to present their Projects of Worth as part of the Law Without Walls programme. Having attended online digital classes over the course of the term with students from law schools including Harvard, Fordham, Stanford, St Gallen, Sydney and New York they worked collaboratively to investigate assigned topics at the cutting edge of developments in law and legal education. These included the disaggregation of legal services, global access to justice, law school debt and publicly-held law firms. A UCL student, Iqra Musaddaq, was on the winning team. Together with students from Stanford and Miami, Iqra designed an innovative online forum for people working in the fight against human trafficking to connect, collaborate and share information and expertise.
Ian Fletcher Addresses Insolvency Research Conference at UCL
On 19 April the sixth Insolvency Research Conference, organised annually by the UK Insolvency Service, was held at Bentham House by invitation of the UCL Institute for Bankruptcy, Restructuring and Insolvency Law (BRIL). The conference, attended by more than 50 academics, practitioners and members of the Insolvency Service, was focused on the international and comparative aspects of insolvency. Professor Ian Fletcher delivered a paper entitled “Shaping Rules of Cooperation in International Insolvency”, in which he explored some of the challenges and outcomes of a six-year research project on transnational insolvency, undertaken on behalf of the American Law Institute and the International Insolvency Institute. Papers were also contributed by Zinian Zhang (Durham), Kristin van Zwieten (Cambridge), Michael Schillig (KCL) and Robin Parsons (Sidley Austin LLP). The concluding panel session provided an opportunity to demonstrate the excellent facilities of the Denys Holland Lecture Theatre, with one of the panellists participating by live video link from the US.
Research Council judges UCL Research Project on Satellites and Environmental Law as 'Outstanding'
The Arts and Humanities Research Council has recently assessed the major three-year research project awarded to UCL Laws between 2005 and 2008 on the use of satellite technology as a compliance tool for environmental enforcement, and given it its highest rating of Outstanding. The project was directed in Laws by Professor Richard Macrory, with Ray Purdy, Senior Research Fellow, as the lead researcher.
The project, with collaboration from the Dept of Geography, explored the potential and significance of employing satellite monitoring data as a compliance tool, in the context of current step changes in resolution capabilities, geographical coverage, and costs of the technology. The AHRC Assessment commented that the research was clearly valuable, with high impact, and was very complimentary about the degree of "very significant" collaborations and interaction, both formal and informal, that had been carried out during the research. It concluded that the project was "excellent value for money".
John Tasioulas Delivers Natural Law Lecture at Notre Dame
John Tasioulas, Quain Professor of Jurisprudence at UCL, delivered the annual Natural Law Lecture on 3 April for Notre Dame Law School’s Natural Law Institute. The lecture was entitled ‘Human Rights, Legitimacy, and International Law’. Professor Tasioulas argued for a conception of human rights as strongly continuous with natural rights in their nature and grounding. Whilst recognising the significance of human rights in assessments of political legitimacy – or the moral bindingness of political institutions, including legal systems – he rejected the idea that human rights are essentially to be characterised by reference to their role in such assessments. Finally, he addressed the legitimacy of international law and explored the ways in which it is constrained by considerations of pluralism, freedom and exceptionalism. A version of the lecture is forthcoming in the American Journal of Jurisprudence, published by the Natural Law Institute.
The Natural Law Institute of Notre Dame Law School was established in 1947. Recent Natural Law lecturers include the legal philosophers John Gardner (Oxford) and Jeremy Waldron (NYU/Oxford) and the theologian Oliver O’Donovan (Edinburgh).
What Would Leadership in Copyright Policy Look Like?
The Hargreaves Review bemoaned the prevalence of lobbynomics and the tendency of policy-driven evidence-making, instead of evidence-driven policy-making. When politicians talk about being leaders, what does it mean to lead when policy is not based on evidence? Who is leading who?
At a lively UCL Institute for Brand and Innovation Law (IBIL) Brands Seminar held on 3 April, William F Patry, Chief Copyright Counsel, Google Inc. discussed the issues and the current state of play on copyright with The Rt Hon Prof Sir Robin Jacob of UCL Laws, who chaired the event. A copyright lawyer for 30 years, Bill Patry previously served as copyright counsel to the US House of Representatives Committee on the Judiciary and as a Policy Planning Advisor to the Register of Copyrights. He is also a prolific writer on copyright. He offered his frank and far-reaching expertise on US and international copyright issues to the UCL audience in attendance.
Richard Moorhead becomes UCL’s first Chair in Law and Professional Ethics
Professor Richard Moorhead, a highly-respected voice in legal education and legal aid, has been appointed as the first Chair in Law and Professional Ethics at University College London. As holder of the Chair, he will take on the Directorship of UCL’s Centre for Ethics and Law, based at UCL Laws. In his new role, Professor Moorhead will advance the strengths and raise the profile of UCL as a world-leading centre of research excellence in law and professional ethics.
The Centre for Ethics and Law fosters intellectual leadership and knowledge-sharing between industry, academics, practitioners, policy-makers and the professions. It recognises that business and the professions are going through profound periods of commercial change. Ethical and reputational concerns are at the heart of many of these changes. Professor Moorhead said: "There has never been a better time to be focusing on ethics. Ethical crises are everywhere. Businesses, professions and the media are discovering that reputational risk damages bottom lines in the short term and legitimacy in the long term. All are struggling with greater accountability and diminished trust. At the same time, technology and the power of markets are challenging conventional modes of regulation. The language of compliance is being exchanged with the language of proper justice, but it remains to be seen if this shift delivers more justice."
Mar 2012
Winston Chu speaks on Law, Environment and Governance: Harbour Reclamation in Hong Kong
The 'Save our Harbour' campaign, undertaken by UCL Laws alumnus Winston Ka-Sun Chu (LLB 1960), spanned the decade of the historic transfer of Hong Kong from British colonial rule to Chinese rule. The campaign saved the city's world famous Victoria Harbour from destruction through a massive reclamation programme proposed by the Government. At an inspiring event on 27 March, Winston Chu discussed the role of the people and the rule of law in his successful campaign to protect the environment and change government policy. His talk was opened with a warm welcome from the Dean of Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn DBE QC and UCL's President and Provost, Professor Malcolm Grant. Faculty members and Laws alumni were out in force, including Emeritus Professors Bin Cheng and Val Korah, who taught Winston Chu while he was a student in the Faculty years ago.
Winston Ka Sun Chu has been a solicitor in Hong Kong since 1964. He served as a member of the Town Planning Board between 1988 to 1996 and later as a member of the Metro Planning Committee and the Lands and Buildings Advisory Committee. He founded the Society for Protection of the Harbour in 1995 and served as its Chairman until 2011. He was directly involved in the enactment of the Protection of the Harbour Ordinance and the two recent judicial reviews concerning harbour reclamation. Winston Chu has been an Honorary Lecturer in the Faculty of Laws, University of Hong Kong since 1984 and a Visiting Professor of Planning Law at UCL Laws and the Bartlett School of the Built Environment since 1995. In 2004 he was voted Legal Personality of the Year by the Asian Legal Business Awards.
UCL Student Jennifer Lim secures a place on the ICJ's traineeship programme
Jennifer Lim, a final year undergraduate at UCL, was recently accepted into the International Court of Justice's nine-month traineeship programme. She is one of 10 trainees selected by the Court through a highly competitive process, from a pool of applicants from top American law schools. In 2010, Ms. Lim transferred to Columbia Law School as part of the UCL-Columbia LLB/JD programme. While at UCL, Ms. Lim was a member of the UCL Jessup team that won the UK National Mooting Championship in 2010. She has continued to participate in the Jessup Moot Court competition at Columbia, winning the Stephen M. Schwebel Best Oralist Award in 2011, and has focused her course work on international arbitration and public international law.
Professor Joanne Scott elected Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh
Joanne Scott, Professor of European Law at UCL, has been elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (RSE), Scotland's National Academy of Arts and Sciences. The RSE was instituted by Royal Charter in 1783 for the Advancement of Learning and Useful Knowledge. This is taken to embrace all fields of scholarship and learning. The primary qualifications for election to Fellowship of the Society are excellence and eminence in the context of its role as Scotland’s national academy.
Ioannis Lianos Speaks to All Party Parliamentary Group at the House of Lords
Dr. Ioannis Lianos of UCL Laws spoke on 20 March at a session organised by the All Party Parliamentary Group on the Constitution at the House of Lords on the legal implications of deeper integration in the Euro zone, following the recent signing of the Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance in the Economic and Monetary Union. The two other contributors were David Rennie (Political editor, The Economist) and Mats Persson (Director, Open Europe) who focused on the political dimension of this new framework of economic governance in the Euro zone. Dr Lianos' contribution examined the legality from the point of EU law of this International agreement between the Euro zone Member States and nine other EU Member States not participating in the Euro (with the exception of Britain and the Czech republic) and the possibilities that this opens for further economic integration in Europe. He also commented on Britain's role in this process and more generally on the implications of deeper integration of the Eurozone for the future of the European project and Britain’s position in it.
Philip Pettit Delivers Inaugural UCL Quain Lecture in Jurisprudence 
Philip Pettit, the Laurance S. Rockefeller University Professor of Politics and Human Values at Princeton University, delivered the inaugural Quain Lecture in Jurisprudence at UCL on 20 March. His lecture, entitled ‘Legitimacy and Justice’, explored the distinction between these two values and argued that the significance of legitimacy has been overlooked in recent political philosophy. Whereas justice is concerned with the moral acceptability of the rules that make up the social order, legitimacy is concerned with the moral acceptability of the coercive imposition of such an order. In his lecture, Professor Pettit drew on a republican conception of liberty to argue that the legitimacy of the state can be sustained in terms of the value of freedom itself, with the result that the coercive imposition of a social order need not involve any sacrifice in the freedom of its citizens.
2012 Bentham Association Presidential Address and Dinner
The Rt Hon Lady Justice Hallett DBE, Bentham Association President 2012, delivered a timely Address entitled 'Independence Under Threat?' to UCL Laws alumni at the 64th annual Bentham Association Dinner held on 14 March. The event was hosted by Bentham Association Chairman, Edwin Glasgow QC, CBE and enjoyed by some 140 alumni guests. After the main lecture, Laws alumni in attendance were treated to a gala dinner, where they networked with new and old friends alike.
Sir Robin Jacob Receives 'Outstanding Achievement in IP' Award
The Rt Hon Professor Sir Robin Jacob, Sir Hugh Laddie Chair of Intellectual Property Law and Co-Director of the Institute of Brand and Innovation Law at UCL, received an 'Outstanding Achievement in IP' Award at the Managing Intellectual Property Awards in London on 15 March. The seventh annual event recognises outstanding achievements in IP practice during the past year in over 50 categories, covering markets from the United Kingdom to Argentina to Vietnam. Sir Robin received one of two awards given on the night for outstanding individual achievement.
Professor Dame Hazel Genn and Professor Philippe Sands make The Times Law 100 List
Dean of UCL Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn DBE QC, and Professor Philippe Sands QC have been named amongst the UK's most influential lawyers in the The Times Law 100 List 2012. They were joined on this year's list by Lady Justice Hallett, 2012 Bentham Association President at UCL Laws, and Distinguished Judicial Visitors to the Faculty The Right Honourable Lord Justice Carnwath and The Right Honourable the Lord Dyson. Sir Jeffrey Jowell QC, former Dean of UCL Laws, was also recognised.
Students Hold Conference on Alternative Environmental Government
LLM Students at UCL and other universities held a highly successful one-day conference on 16 March at the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies entitled ‘Alternative Environmental Government’. Key speakers at the 2012 PIEL Conference included Nicholas de Sadeleer from Université Catholique de Louvain, Emma Dickson from Blackstone Chambers, Paul Horsman from Greenpeace and Polly Higgins, barrister. The day was rounded off with a debate on the need for a new International Court of the Environment chaired by Stephen Hockman QC.
Public Interest Environmental Law (PIEL) is now in its sixth year and completely student run. The Conference has built up a strong reputation for excellence in bringing legal practitioners, academics and related professionals together with students to discuss and debate pertinent issues relating to environmental law.
UCL Laws Student Prizewinners Ceremony 2012
The Faculty's Student Prizewinners Ceremony is one of the highlights of the academic year, when we gather to celebrate student achievement. Our prizes and scholarships are awarded to students who have achieved top marks in their examinations at UCL or whose academic distinction is such that a scholarship has been awarded to provide the opportunity to study here. This year's sparkling ceremony was held on 7 March 2012, with many talented students, proud families, Faculty staff and friends in attendance.
To be awarded a Faculty prize or scholarship is to be given significant recognition as truly outstanding amongst one's student peers. Many congratulations to all of this year's hard working prize winners. Sincere thanks also our many sponsors, old and new, whose ongoing and generous support allows us to encourage and recognise student potential, and reward student excellence.
Antonios Tzanakopoulos Invited to take part in Australian UN workshops
Dr Antonios Tzanakopoulos, Lecturer at UCL Laws, has been invited to participate in workshops at the Permanent Mission of Australia to the United Nations in New York. The workshops are part of an Australian Research Council sponsored Linkage Project entitled “Strengthening the Rule of Law through the UN Security Council”, which is a collaboration between the Australian Government’s Australian Civil-Military Centre (formerly the Asia Pacific Civil-Military Centre of Excellence) and the Australian National University’s Centre for International Governance and Justice.
UCL Laws Students Win National Client Interviewing Competition
UCL Laws students Flo Jones and Katy Matthews have won the prize for best undergraduate team at the national finals of the Client Interviewing Competition for England and Wales 2012. The finals were held at the University of Sussex on 3 March and featured nine teams (pared down from 26 in the two regional finals). Teams were comprised of undergraduate law students, GDL students or students on professional training courses. The Competition assesses crucial interviewing and counselling skills needed within the legal profession. Congratulations to Katy and Flo on winning the undergraduate trophy.
UCL Laws Faculty, Alumni and Friends Take Silk
Dawn Oliver, Emeritus Professor of Constitutional Law and Principal Research Associate at UCL Laws, has been appointed Honorary Silk (Queen's Counsel honoris causa). Honorary Silk is awarded to those who have made a major contribution to the law of England and Wales outside practice in the courts, and recipients are appointed through nominations received from the legal sector and general public. Traditionally, honorary silk has been awarded to distinguished legal academics and to some lawyers in public service for achievements beyond their normal responsibilities. Only a very small number are awarded each year.
The Faculty would also like to congratulate Laws alumnus Suzanne Ornsby (LLB 1985) who has been appointed Queen's Counsel (QC). The rank of Queen's Counsel is awarded to barristers and solicitors who have demonstrated particular skill and expertise in the conduct of advocacy. It has been awarded in various forms for some 400 years. Since 2005, an independent Selection Panel has made recommendations to the Lord Chancellor, using a new system of assessment based on competencies and rigorous analysis of evidence.
In addition, UCL Laws would like to congratulate James Laddie (son of the late Sir Hugh Laddie) and Stephen Grosz, friends of the Faculty, both of whom have been named QCs. The Silk Ceremony will be held on Friday 30 March 2012.
Feb 2012
Barristers' Cocktail Party 2012
The UCL Laws Annual Barristers' Cocktail Party took place on 22 February 2012 and was attended by seniors judges and barristers from leading sets of Chambers in London. Over 100 students were in attendance to meet barristers in an informal setting and find out more about a career at the Bar. It provided an excellent opportunity for students to learn what a career at the Bar entails and how to enhance their prospects of success. The students and Faculty also used the occasion to express gratitude to those barristers and judges who so graciously give up their time to support mooting and other student activities at UCL Laws.
Ronan McCrea Appointed to International Bar Association Fact-Finding Mission
UCL Laws lecturer Dr. Ronan McCrea has been appointed to a fact-finding mission of the International Bar Association charged with investigating the compliance of the new Hungarian constitution with the rule of law. He joins a mission made up of a former judge of the Court of Justice of the European Union and a former judge of the European Court of Human Rights as well as a member of the South African Law Commission. The mission will be travelling to Hungary in late March with politicians, members of the judiciary and the diplomatic corps in addition to NGO's and civil society organisations before drawing up its report.
Stephen Gurman starts work as new Faculty-based Careers Consultant
UCL Laws is pleased to announce that it is now able to offer careers guidance within the Faculty exclusively tailored for LLB and LLM students. The sessions with the Faculty’s own Careers Consultant, Stephen Gurman, are designed to make careers guidance easily accessible to students. Stephen was previously in private practice at a large international firm of solicitors. The one to one sessions available are:
- Short Guidance – a chance to talk about your career options and to ask for help with preparing CVs and application forms. Students can attend as many of these sessions as they like. Sign–up sheets will be posted each morning outside G32.
- Practice Interviews – for when you have an interview and would like to practice and receive feedback on your performance. The practice interview will be tailored to the types of questions the employer you have the real interview with would typically ask.
- Longer Career Discussions – available by referral for those who have attended a Short Guidance session and would benefit from a more in-depth discussion.
For full details of the sessions and to find out how to sign up, please see the noticeboards in the Cissy Chu Common Room.
Freshfields and UCL launch new scholarships to tackle social mobility
International law firm Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer has entered into a partnership with UCL Laws to provide two scholarships per year for law students from socially and economically less privileged backgrounds. As well as providing financial support, the scheme will see Freshfields offer successful candidates eight weeks paid work experience per academic year and the guarantee of a training contract interview, which, if successful, will see the students benefit from a grant covering the full cost of law school. The scheme’s key features include:
- eligible candidates will be students from socially and economically less privileged backgrounds, for example those who would be first generation graduates;
- the promise of academic achievement and the potential to succeed as a City lawyer will be the key criterion: the interview process will take into account the social circumstances of the candidates;
- successful candidates will receive a £10,000 bursary from Freshfields to cover their maintenance expenses and will also be eligible to participate in UCL’s bursary scheme to provide additional support of up to £3,500, making it one of the most generous scholarships available at UCL
Dame Hazel Genn, Dean of Laws at UCL, said: "The UCL Laws Faculty is thrilled to be working with Freshfields to offer this opportunity to outstanding students from lower socio-economic backgrounds. It is a significant contribution to the objective of improving social mobility." The scholarship will commence in the 2012 academic year. More details will be released at a later date.
Trade Marks and the Internet: US and European Views
What amounts to a trade mark infringement on the Internet is a matter of vital commercial importance. Both the question of whether there is an infringement and who should be liable are subjects of wide debate and argument. These questions are increasingly coming before the courts on both sides of the Atlantic. Is a common approach possible or necessary?
At an incisive event hosted by UCL’s Institute of Brand and Innovation Law on 15 February, Professor Barton Beebe (NYU) and Alexander von Muhlendahl (Bardehle Pagenberg, former Vice-President of OHIM) discussed the current state of trade mark law in the US and Europe, and where it may be heading. The comparative simplicity of the US approach compared with the complexity and uncertainty of the European position was made apparent for all. The event was chaired by The Hon Mr Justice Arnold who has given some of the key judgments in this area. Both speakers have kindly agreed to provide versions of their papers for publication on the IBIL website.
Professor Paul Mitchell delivers Inaugural UCL Lecture
On 9 February, Professor Paul Mitchell delivered his inaugural lecture at UCL on the subject of 'Patterns of Legal Change'. He argued that study of the processes of legal change has been neglected, and left to legal historians, when in fact understanding how and why law changes is necessary and important for everyone who works in law. He particularly emphasised the importance of looking beyond formal legal materials such as law reports and texts of statutes, so as to identify the underlying causes of change.
UCL Bindmans Debate 2012: Freedom of the Press v. Privacy Rights
On 8 February, the 2012 UCL Bindmans Debate discussed a number of timely issues surrounding self or statutory regulation of the press. How might the current system be reformed? Should regulation be scrapped altogether or is full statutory regulation the answer? Panellists Tessa Jowell, Labour MP for Dulwich and West Norwood; Martin Moore, Director, Media Standards Trust; Max Mosley, Former President, Formula 1 and Gill Phillips, Director of Editorial Legal Services at The Guardian discussed the pros and cons. This lively debate was chaired by Hugh Tomlinson QC, Matrix Chambers.
Ray Purdy Interviewed by BBC News on Satellite Monitoring
Spying on Europe’s farms with satellites and drones is becoming more common, according to a recent article by BBC News. "Europe's farms cost taxpayers billions of euros in subsidies each year, and EU agricultural inspectors are turning to technology to improve their patchy record on preventing fraud and waste." Ray Purdy, a senior researcher at UCL Laws specialising in satellite monitoring, was interviewed by the BBC on the legality of this activity and the response from farmers to similar surveillance in the UK and Australia. He said there have been few prosecutions in the UK to date based on satellite evidence.
Brüstle v Greenpeace: Has the European Court seriously damaged stem cell research?
The Court of Justice of the European Union recently published its decision in Brüstle v Greenpeace, declaring that a process which involves removal of a stem cell from a human embryo at the blastocyst stage, entailing the destruction of that embryo, cannot be patented. There is a widespread view that the Court's decision provides a significant bar to patentability in this area.
A multidisciplinary event on 1 February, hosted jointly by UCL’s Institute of Brand and Innovation Law (IBIL) and the UCL Centre for Stem Cells and Regenerative Medicine, explored the legal limits of this decision. Dr Justin Turner QC, 3 New Square Chambers, Professor Pete Coffey, UCL Centre for Stem Cells and Regenerative Medicine and Professor Jo Wolff, UCL Department of Philosophy examined the practical and ethical implications of this ruling. The event was chaired by The Rt Hon Professor Sir Robin Jacob, Sir Hugh Laddie Chair of Intellectual Property Law and Co-Director of IBIL at UCL’s Faculty of Laws.
Jan 2012
Dean of UCL Laws, Hazel Genn, Visits University of Namibia
On 16 January, Dean of UCL Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn, visited the University of Namibia (UNAM) and met with representatives from the University's Law Faculty and its Faculty of Medicine. She was treated to a warm welcome by faculty members and staff, and their discussions about the potential for UNAM law students to study at UCL and the development of supportive links between UCL and the University of Namibia were very positive. After meetings and lunch, Dean Genn then met with Her Excellency, the British High Commissioner in Namibia. It is hoped that this visit will help to foster relations between UCL and University of Namibia.
Hiroshi Oda receives Order of Friendship from Russian Federation
Professor Hiroshi Oda of UCL Laws has received the Order of Friendship, conferred on him personally by Russia’s President Medvedev. The award marks Prof Oda’s contribution to Russian law, and in particular his book on Russian Commercial Law. The ceremony was conducted under the auspices of Russia’s Supreme Commercial Court as part of their 20th anniversary, and was attended by almost one thousand judges and lawyers from around the world.
Dr Ioannis Appointed Visiting Professor at the University of Chile's Faculty of Law Ioannis Lianos
Dr Ioannis Lianos has been appointed a visiting professor at the University of Chile, Faculty of Law, in Santiago. The University of Chile is one of the major research universities in South America. Dr Lianos, Director of UCL's Centre for Law, Economics and Society, will engage in a close collaboration for funding applications with the RegCom, the Centre for competition and regulation at the University of Chile, in particular for activities in South America.
Flo Jones and Katy Matthews place second in the Regional Finals of the national Client Interviewing Competition
The winning team in the UCL Macfarlanes Client Interviewing Competition, Flo Jones and Katy Matthews, came second in the Regional Finals of the national Client Interviewing Competition. Vying against students from universities and vocational educational providers across the country, the team have secured a place in the National Finals to be held in March 2012.
The Triumph of Human Rights: Dream or Nightmare?
A growing backlash can now be detected against the apparently ever-expanding scope of human rights guarantees. Politicians attack courts for stretching the meaning of rights too far, while political philosophers regularly express concerns about the "inflation" of the concept of rights. Underlying this discussion is the existence of two divergent accounts of rights. The "minimalist" account sees human rights as focused on protecting what Isaiah Berlin described as "negative liberty", and is sceptical of attempts to stretch rights to encompass socio-economic claims and other "positive" entitlements. The "maximalist" account embraces the ever-expanding scope of rights discourse and is confident of the capacity of human rights law and practice to protect vital human interests.
In a UCL Lunch Hour Lecture delivered on 26 January, Colm O'Cinneide of UCL Laws provided an insightful account of these timely issues. He stated that there are reasons to tread cautiously when it comes to expanding the scope of human rights claims: however, the minimalist account ultimately cannot give a coherent justification of the limits it wants to maintain.
Ronan McCrea interviewed on the EU Fiscal Treaty and National Law
"Ireland may still have to hold a referendum on Europe's new fiscal treaty even if the government decides next month that it does not need a popular vote to sign up to the pact," according to a recent article by Reuters. Laws Lecturer Ronan McCrea was interviewed for the piece on how EU law, the Euro and the Irish constitution apply to this important decision.
Ronan Mcrea was also interviewed by European news magazine Der Spiegel, where he responded to doubts over the status of the proposed EU Fiscal Treaty in national law.
John Tasioulas gives UCL Inaugural Lecture 'Towards a Philosophy of Human Rights' 
John Tasioulas, Quain Professor of Jurisprudence, delivered his inaugural lecture on 19 January to a capacity audience at UCL. In attendance were some of the world's leading legal and moral philosophers, including Emeritus Quain Professor Ronald Dworkin. The lecture was chaired by Baroness Onora O'Neill, former President of the British Academy and introduced by UCL Provost Malcolm Grant and Dean of UCL Laws, Dame Professor Hazel Genn.
Professor Tasioulas' lecture, entitled 'Towards a Philosophy of Human Rights', advanced a doubly pluralistic conception of human rights according to which they are broadly equivalent to the traditional idea of natural rights. On the one hand, there is a plurality of values that ground human rights; in particular, these values include the full range of human interests, not just our basic needs or our interest in freedom. On the other hand, human rights perform a plurality of political functions, such as acting as benchmarks of governmental legitimacy or triggers for international intervention. However, it is a mistake to characterize the essential nature of human rights by reference to any of these functions. Professor Tasioulas concluded by arguing that our commitment to human rights must be grounded in what we take to be wider truths about morality, human nature and human flourishing, and that attempts to give human rights a basis independent of truth, in the hope of avoiding 'ethnocentrism', were misguided.
Professor Cheryl Thomas Interviewed for BBC Radio 4's World at One
After the jailing of juror Theodora Dallas for contempt of court, UCL Laws Professor Cheryl Thomas comments that a quarter of jurors in high profile court cases have seen something about the defendant on the internet during the trial.
Listen to Radio 4's World at One 23 Jan (from 18mins 27s)
Douglas Guilfoyle Interviewed by Radio 4's Saturday PM programme
Douglas Guilfoyle, Senior Lecturer at UCL Laws, was interviewed by Radio 4's Saturday PM programme about options for the Royal Navy, after news that they had captured 13 suspected Somali pirates in the Indian Ocean. The interview can be heard again on the Saturday PM website (26 minutes in). Douglas was also quoted in the related BBC news article online.
Joanne Scott Awarded Leverhulme Trust Major Research Fellowship
Joanne Scott, Professor of European Law at UCL, has been awarded a Leverhulme Trust Major Research Fellowship for 24 months, effective 1 September 2012. These awards enable well-established and distinguished researchers in the disciplines of the Humanities and Social Sciences to devote themselves to a single research project of outstanding originality and significance, capable of completion within two or three years; and are particularly aimed at those who are or have been prevented by routine duties from completing a programme of original research. The Leverhulme Trust will fund a replacement lecturer at UCL Laws for the term of Professor Scott's research. Her project details are as follows:
The Global Reach of EU Climate Change Law: A Game-Changing Strategy?
The European Union (EU) has placed itself at the heart of the drive to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions. It not only pursues this aim internally but also externally through the ‘global reach’ of its climate change law. It is this extra-territorial ambition of EU law that forms the heart of this research. Joanne Scott argues that the EU is pursuing an innovative strategy that she calls ‘contingent unilateralism’. Her project assesses the legality, equity and effectiveness of this strategy and argues that a new mode of global leadership is emerging that challenges both unilateralist and multilateralist interpretations of global governance.
Philippe Sands co-authors 'Guantanamo: An Oral History' for Vanity Fair
January 11 2012 marks the 10th anniversary of the arrival of the first detainees at the US detention facility at Guantánamo Bay. In a recent article for Vanity Fair, entitled 'Guantánamo: An Oral History', co-author and UCL Laws Professor Philippe Sands QC captures the experiences of a range of people associated with Guantánamo, including lawyers, soldiers, diplomats and former detainees. Most interviews for the piece were conducted from 2009–11, although several were conducted earlier by Philippe Sands in the course of the research for his book Torture Team.
Dec 2011
UCL Bite-Sized Lecture: 'Little Dorrit or the Artful Dodger? Telling Tales while writing Bankruptcy Law'
On 16 December 2011, Joseph Spooner (PhD Candidate and Teaching Fellow, Faculty of Laws) delivered a presentation entitled 'Little Dorrit or the Artful Dodger? Telling Tales while writing Bankruptcy Laws' as part of the UCL Bite-Sized Lunchtime Lectures series. Joseph’s research involves comparative analysis of national personal bankruptcy laws within the European Union, and his talk explored differences in national laws by identifying the contrasting dominant constructions of the character of “the debtor” that underpin bankruptcy legislation in a selection of European countries.
Antonios Tzanakopoulos awarded the Georges Tenekides prize for best doctoral thesis
Antonios Tzanakopoulos, Lecturer at UCL Laws, has been awarded the Georges Tenekides prize for the best doctoral thesis 2009-10 by the Hellenic Society of International Law and International Relations. The award is for the PhD thesis on which his OUP monograph Disobeying the Security Council: Countermeasures against Wrongful Sanctions (Oxford Monographs in International Law, OUP, 2011) is based. The prize comes with a € 1,000 grant. The Prize Committee was unanimous in its decision.
As stated (in a translation from Greek): "The Society has established a prize for the best doctoral thesis in international law and international relations in honour of Georges Tenékidès, a Greek international lawyer of great repute. The competition is open to all Greek men and women who have submitted a doctoral thesis during the competition period. The prize is awarded every two years at the Society's annual conference. Past recipients of the prize include Linos-Alexandre Sicilianos, currently Judge at the European Court of Human Rights."
- Hellenic Society website (English version)
- Antonios Tzanakopoulos
Students Flo Jones and Katy Matthews win Macfarlanes Client Interviewing Competition
The annual Macfarlanes student Client Interviewing Competition at UCL was won by Flo Jones and Katy Matthews in a very close final round against Sebastian Ion and Angus Nunn. The final was judged by representatives from the competition’s sponsor, Macfarlanes, John Hornby, the firm’s partner responsible for graduate recruitment and Helen Edwards, a UCL Laws alumna. The student winners will represent UCL in the national client interviewing competition and have the opportunity to attend an assessment day for a summer vacation scheme at Macfarlanes.
Lord Irvine headlines sold-out event on A British Intrepretation of Convention Rights
Lord Irvine of Lairg, Lord Chancellor from 1997-2003 and architect of the Human Rights Act (HRA), headlined a sold-out event at UCL's Cruciform LectureTheatre on 14 December. The event was chaired and co-hosted by Professor Dame Hazel Genn DBE QC, Dean of UCL Laws and Co-Director of the UCL Judicial Institute, and Professor Sir Jeffery Jowell KCMG QC, Director for the Bingham Centre for the Rule of Law. Some 350 guests attended the lecture.
In his talk, entitled 'A British Interpretation of Convention Rights', Lord Irvine spoke publicly for the first time on his intent in creating Section 2 of the HRA, and its subsequent interpretation. As reported by the Guardian: "Irvine argued that Section 2, which governs the prominence given to Strasbourg jurisprudence, has been misinterpreted and therefore human rights case law has developed on a false premise. He added that 'the domestic courts have strayed considerably from giving effect to parliament's intention'. The system of binding precedent, where lower courts follow the decisions of those above them, has led to judges mistakenly thinking they are 'effectively subordinate' to the Strasbourg court."
Ronan McCrea of UCL Laws publishes article in The Irish Times
Laws Lecturer Dr Ronan McCrea has written an article in The Irish Times, 15 December edition. He argues that a referendum on the budgetary agreement by EU leaders may not be necessary under the Irish constitution and criticises referendums as a means of political decision-making.
Competition Law and Policy in the Healthcare Sector: A Trans-Atlantic Perspective
Important reforms of the healthcare sector in the United States and the UK, in particular the way each jurisdiction deals with anti-competitive behaviour, have been the focus of a seminar organised by the Centre for Law, Economics and Society (CLES) at UCL on 6 December, chaired by Dr Ioannis Lianos, director of the Centre.
The Deputy Assistant Attorney General of the US Department of Justice, Professor Fiona Scott Morton, discussed the enforcement of competition law in the (mostly private) US healthcare sector. Much healthcare provision in the US is accomplished through networks of providers such as physicians, hospitals, pharmacies, and dentists, which may raise competition concerns. Catherine Davies, director of the UK Co-operation and Competition Panel, discussed recent regulatory reforms of the (mixed economy) system of healthcare in the UK. Professor Pierre Regibeau, CRA and Imperial College, commented on the competition economics aspects of contracts that reference rivals. A major conference on this issue is planned to take place after the enactment of the Health and Social Care Bill in 2012.
Centre for Law, Economics and Society Holds Brands, Competition and IP Law Conference
The Centre for Law, Economics and Society (CLES) at UCL organised a conference on 'Brands: Competition and IP Law', in collaboration with IBIL at UCL and Loyola University of Chicago's Institute for Consumer Antitrust Studies. The event was held on 2 December at UCL Laws. The aim of this conference, attended by more than 180 delegates from industry, the public sector, law firms and economic consultancies, was to reflect on the legal and economic understanding of brands by explaining what brands are and how they function, how trademark and competition law integrate brands in their framework, if this is satisfactory, as well as the role brands play in business competition.
The conference also delved into specific issues raised by branding in 21st-century business competition, such as the challenges raised by online business and the increasing role of private labels in distribution. The Centre will co-organise a follow-up conference on the emergent field of brand law (as a unifying theme for both trademark law, unfair competition and antitrust/merger law) at Chicago in October 2012. A volume presenting the main lessons/conclusions from both conferences and providing a comparative (EU and US law) perspective will appear in 2013.
- Dr. Ioannis Lianos (conference organiser)
Nov 2011
When European Citizens Complain: The European Network of Ombudsmen and Accountability Networks
Organised jointly by UCL Laws (Professor Richard Rawlings) and the LSE Law Department (Professor Carol Harlow), and held on 25 November, this workshop was a truly pioneering one. Set against the backdrop of multiple developments in multi-level administrative action beyond the State, the workshop thus opened up both academic and practitioner perspectives on the growth of networks that hold decision-makers to account in the context of EU governance.
Focusing in particular on the role and contribution of the European Network of Ombudsmen, the workshop featured contributions from the European Ombudsman, Nikiforos Diamandouros, and the UK Parliamentary and Health Services Ombudsman, Ann Abraham. Professor Rawlings, who introduced proceedings, highlighted the special value of the workshop in bringing together national and EU colleagues from a variety of disciplines.
Dr Ioannis Lianos appointed a Fellow at the ANU's Centre for Law and Economics
Ioannis Lianos, Director of the Centre for Law, Economics & Society at UCL Laws, has been appointed a Fellow at the Centre for Law and Economics at the Australian National University (ANU). The Centre for Law and Economics at ANU is the only Centre for Law and Economics in Australia and is funded by the Australian federal government. The UCL Centre for Law, Economics & Society will engage in a close collaboration for funding applications with the CLE at ANU, in particular for activities in South East Asia and Oceania.
Institute for Brand and Innovation Law: Conor v Angiotech on Appeal
Conor v Angiotech was a real case in which the House of Lords reversed concurrent findings of obviousness by the High Court and the Court of Appeal. The House of Lords agreed with the Dutch court which had decided the parallel case in Holland. A sold out UCL Laws event on 23 November revisited this important patent law case and related arguments.
The event took the form of a moot between Lord Hoffmann (l) and the Rt. Hon. Professor Sir Robin Jacob of UCL Laws (r), who raised fundamental questions about the law of obviousness. A neutral introduction to the problem was followed by legal argument from the two 'counsel' (who themselves had given the lead judgments in the Court of Appeal and House of Lords respectively). The 'Judge', Justice Rothstein of the Canadian Supreme Court (pictured centre), flew in to London especially for the event, and acted as an 'international' arbitrator. Members of the audience were invited to join the debate, as well as the equally lively drinks reception afterwards.
Mishcon Lecture 2011: British Foreign Policy in a Changing World
This year's Mishcon Lecture 2011 'British Foreign Policy in a Changing World' was delivered by Lord Malloch Brown, Chairman, EMEA & Global Affairs, FTI Consulting Inc. Lord Malloch-Brown served as a Minister in Gordon Brown’s cabinet, where he had particular responsibility for strengthening relationships with Africa and Asia. The Prime Minister appointed him envoy in preparation for the London G-20 Summit. In addition, Lord Malloch-Brown served as Deputy Secretary General and Chief of Staff of the UN under Kofi Annan and, for six years prior, as Administrator of the UN Development Programme. Before that he was a Vice-President at the World Bank. The event, held on 22 November, was chaired by Joshua Rozenberg of Radio 4's Law in Action and introduced by Dean of UCL Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn.
The Mishcon Lectures were established at UCL in 1990, in honour of Lord Mishcon, to mark his 75th birthday. They recognise his achievements and service in the fields of law, education, religion, government and politics. The eclectic nature of the lectures reflect UCL's wish to encompass as wide a spectrum of social, economic, moral, legal and political issues as possible, reflecting Lord Mishcon's career and interests.
Going low carbon: governing climate change technologies 
On 23 November, UCL's Centre for Law and the Environment and UCL Public Policy held an event exploring the governance of the technologies in moving to a low carbon economy. Chiara Armeni and Maria Lee from the Faculty of Laws spoke at the event, chaired by Yvonne Rydin (UCL Bartlett and Environment Institute), along with UCL colleagues Simon Lock (Science and Technology Studies) and Tadj Oreszczyn (Energy Institute).
Technological innovation is expected to play a significant role in moving to a low carbon economy. Alongside the technological and scientific challenges, this presents considerable challenges of governance. The speakers and audience explored the complex governance challenges associated with capturing the carbon savings potential of technological innovation, as well as the ways in which publics might engage with climate change technologies. Any technology is embedded in its social context, and the public in their diverse roles (as citizens, consumers, members of communities) play unavoidable and important roles in the adoption, proliferation and impact of climate change technologies.
The event was supported by UCL Grand Challenges.
IBIL/Marques Event: Questions for Trade Mark Judges
On 16 November, UCL IBIL, together with MARQUES, the Association of European Trade Mark Owners, hosted ‘Questions for the Trade Mark Judges’. The event provided an opportunity for stakeholders to quiz those who make the decisions which affect them and their clients. Topics included how to simplify the trade mark system, whether registries should be bound by their own decisions, whether Advocate Generals add anything of value to CJEU decisions and whether trade mark law needs a parody defence.
In the hot seat were representatives from the major trade mark decision makers in the UK and Europe, namely, the Hon. Mr Justice Arnold (High Court), Gordon Humphreys, (member of 2nd, 3rd and 5th Boards of Appeal, OHIM), Amanda Michaels (Appointed Person) and Allan James (Senior Hearing Officer and Head of Trade Mark Tribunal, UK IPO). The Rt. Hon. Professor Sir Robin Jacob (former Court of Appeal Judge and Hugh Laddie Professor of Intellectual Property) took the role of chair cum agent provocateur.
UCL Judicial Institute hosts UK Supreme Court seminar and launches new UKSC Project
On 18 November, the UCL Judicial Institute (JI) held a morning seminar to mark the second anniversary of the establishment of the United Kingdom Supreme Court and to launch the UCL JI UK Supreme Court Project. The event was attended by 10 current and former Justices of the UK Supreme Court, the Master of the Rolls, the President of Tribunals, judges of the Court of Appeal, Scottish Court of Session, Irish Supreme Court and French Constitutional Court, along with a invitation-only audience of leading counsel, academics, policy-makers and officials of the UKSC.
The UCL JI Co-Director and Dean of UCL Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn, chaired the seminar’s two panel discussions, and UCL JI Co-Director, Professor Cheryl Thomas, presented the first analysis to emerge from the new UCL JI UKSC Project on the work of the Court. The first panel discussion addressed the Internal Workings of the Court and included Permissions to Appeal, Panel Size and Composition, and Judgments of the Court. Expert commentary was provided by Justices of the UK Supreme Court, Lord Dyson, Lady Hale and Lord Mance, along with Lord Neuberger, Master of the Rolls, and Olivier Dutheillet de Lamothe, former justice of the French Constitutional Court.
The second panel discussion addressed External Relations between the UK Supreme Court and other courts in both the UK and Europe, and relations between the Court and government. Expert commentary in this session was provided by Lord Phillips, President of the UK Supreme Court; Lord Justice Carnwath, President of Tribuanls; Lord Hodge, Scottish Court of Session; Mrs Justice Fidelma Macken, Irish Supreme Court; former Attorney General, Baroness Scotland; and Shadow Spokesperson for Justice, Lord Bach.
Tweeting to Topple Tyranny: Social Media and Corporate Social Responsibility
On 15 November, the UCL Centre for Ethics & Law held its third annual lecture “Tweeting to Topple Tyranny: Social Media and Corporate Social Responsibility.” The lecture was presented by Professor Erika George (S. J. Quinney College of Law, University of Utah) together with Dr Nina Seppala of UCL and chaired by the Dean of UCL Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn.
Reflecting the Centre’s multi-disciplinary approach, the lecture attracted a large audience from academia, industry and practice, leading to a lively debate on the issues raised. Professor George discussed the question of whether the special relationship that we all have with social media gave rise to particular obligations regarding social responsibility (arguing that it did). Dr Seppala also considered the role of social media in democracy and considered both the political role of corporations operating social media sites and their responsibility for content posted on such sites.
Dr Ioannis Lianos Awarded Gutenberg Research Chair
Ioannis Lianos of UCL Laws has been awarded the Gutenberg Research Chair at the Ecole National d'Administration (ENA), the elite public policy and administration school of the French Republic. Gutenberg Chairs are programmes organised by the local authorities of the French “Alsace” region on the suggestion of the Cercle Gutenberg. The duration of the Chair is approximately one year and its recipients receive the following: a) The Gutenberg Prize, worth 10,000 euros, given personally; and b) specific financial help of 50,000 euros attributed to the host institution and reserved entirely for the execution of their research project. The ENA and the French government have also made a financial contribution to this project.
Dr Lianos’s research will focus on the analysis of national experiences of EU countries, looking at their various Regulatory Impact Assessments (RIAs). Its objective will be to understand the wider political context that might influence impact assessment methodology and its implementation. A second angle will explore the impact of RIAs in the decision-making process. A third angle will look at the implementation of impact assessments at the local level and, in particular, their role in the devolution or decentralisation process in select EU Member States.
The research will be completed in the next 18 months at the ENA and University College London.
Children's Rights: Progress and Perspectives 
More has been written about children, childhood and children’s rights in the last 20 years than in the rest of history. There are more university courses focusing on children now than ever before. The International Journal of Children’s Rights has been a major player in all this. This volume has been compiled not only to commemorate the journal’s work, but also the 20th anniversary of the Convention coming into operation, and of the first World Summit on Children. This collection contains 20 essays on a range of children's rights issues, including theory, principles, problem areas and history. As well as editing the full volume, Professor Michael Freeman of UCL Laws has also contributed an article.
Trade Mark Dilution in Europe and the United States
This new book by Ilanah Simon Fhima is the only comparison of EU and US protection against trade mark dilution. It provides a complete overview of the dilution action, enabling readers to better protect trade marks against dilution or to combat dilution claims. By examining the justifications offered for dilution, the book places the dilution action in the wider context of the trade mark system, allowing readers to understand the issues behind the law and to consider whether the law appropriately meets these justifications. It considers the fundamental questions raised about trade marks, including whether the main aim of trade marks is to protect the public from being confused, or the investment of trade mark owners in building up their reputations. The book also considers how well the EU and the US take these questions into account in balancing the interests of trade mark owners, their competitors and the public through the dilution action.
UCL Carbon Capture Legal Programme launches EU Case Study Report 
On 7 November, UCL's Carbon Capture Legal Programme (CCLP) released a series of case study reports analysing the implementation of the EU’s “Directive on the Geological Storage of CO2” in six selected European countries, which provides a legal framework for carrying out carbon capture and storage (CCS) in Europe.
The objective of the reports was to understand the rationale behind each country’s choices in implementing specific aspects of the Directive into their national laws. The CCLP commissioned environmental law experts in the various countries to write the reports. The UK report was authored by UCL Laws Research Associate, Chiara Armeni.
To launch the reports, the CCLP held a one-day conference where the authors of the case studies presented their findings for the first time. The event attracted key CCS stakeholders from industry, government and research organisations as well as a number of environmental law academics from across Europe.
Dr Arad Reisberg contributes to Westminster launch of the report Transforming Capitalism from Within
Dr Arad Reisberg of UCL Laws was invited to participate in and made contributions to the Palace of Westminster launch of the report Transforming Capitalism from Within (Rushworth & Schluter, 2011) held on 3 November 2011.
The event was sponsored by the Rt Hon. Stephen Timms MP and Jeremy Lefroy MP. This was in recognition of Dr Reisberg's help and support producing Transforming Capitalism from Within. University College London is also mentioned in the report foreword. Since 2007 Dr Reisberg has been acting as an Academic Advisor to a major Research Project entitled ‘The Relational Company: Exploring a New Business Vehicle as An Alternative Company Structure’, also commissioned by the Relationships Foundation.
Jurisprudence Review launches Vol. 17 by hosting debate on free speech and privacy
On 1 November, the 17th volume of the UCL Jurisprudence Review was launched with a debate on 'The Normative Value of Free Speech and Privacy'. At the beginning of the session the annual UCL Jurisprudence Review 2011 Writing Prize for the best essay published in the Review was awarded to student Mark Rowlands. Dean of UCL Laws, Professor Dame Hazel Genn, noted the Review’s proud and enduring legacy of scholarship and its significant contribution to legal philosophy. A number of speakers were then invited to approach the topic of free speech and privacy.
The event’s chair, Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury (Master of the Rolls) appreciated that “the carriers of a right to free speech hold duties as well.” Professor Eric Barendt (UCL Laws) opened the debate by pointing out that “the concept of privacy in Britain is so uncertain that we do not even know how to pronounce it.” Professor Leslie Green (University of Oxford) noted that “duties fall not only to speakers but also to listeners.” A more practical approach was presented by Charlotte Harris (Mishcon de Reya), who argued that “tabloids need us to have a private life since their existence and commercial value depends on it.” The Rt Hon Sir Stephen Sedley delivered the final presentation, in which he focused on the current level of protection of the right to privacy and concluded that “the Courts need to consider the effects on someone’s life when his private life is published through a tabloid.”
UCL Lunch Hour Lecture: Prof Alison Diduck on 'London, the divorce capital of the world'
The law gives the courts very broad discretion to determine ‘fair’ property and financial awards when couples divorce. While that discretion is exercised in all cases, it has been shaped by principles developed in the so-called ‘big money’ cases decided in the Appeal Courts since 2000, which have led to increased awards to homemaker wives. Many are unhappy with this turn of events and have said that London has now become the 'divorce capital of the world'.
In a UCL Lunch Hour Lecture given to a public audience on 1 November, Professor Diduck discussed these ‘big money' divorce cases and the payouts involved, speaking to matters of fairness, gender and judicial discretion. She argued that if London’s status as 'divorce capital' was about implementing an ideal of fairness and gender equality in divorce settlement, then that is no bad thing.
The US Environmental Court: Lessons for the UK?
November 2nd is the 21st anniversary of the Vermont Environmental Court, the only such specialist court in the United States. Thus, the timing was right for a UCL seminar the previous night organised by the UK Environmental Law Association and the Centre for Law and the Environment where Judge Merideth Wright, the first judge at the Vermont court, gave an account of its workings to an audience of British lawyers and Faculty LLM students.
The UCL event was chaired by Lord Justice Carnwath, Senior President of Tribunals in this country. Judge Wright's talk was especially timely because a specialist environmental tribunal is now in the process of being established in England and Wales. Its initial jurisdiction will be to hear appeals against new forms of civil penalties being introduced into environmental law, but its functions may well extend in future to cover other areas of environmental regulation such as appeals against refusal of a waste management licences.
Judge Wright's presentation was followed by a panel discussion involving Mr Justice Keith Lindblom; Nick Warren, President General Regulatory Chamber and Professor Richard Macrory QC of UCL, author of a recent report on strengthening the new environmental tribunal. It became clear during the seminar that, despite the very different legal systems, there were extremely valuable lessons to be learnt from the Vermont experience at a critical time in thinking about new UK institutional arrangements for handling environmental law.
Oct 2011
Professor Philip Schofield gives Conway Memorial Lecture 2011
In this year’s Conway Memorial Lecture held on 27 October, Philip Schofield, Director of the Bentham Project at UCL discussed the recently uncovered, almost prophetic writings of philosopher and reformer Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832) concerning the teachings of St Paul and the nature of sexuality and morality.
The prestigious annual Conway Memorial Lecture is given in honour of Moncure Conway, the American abolitionist and biographer of Thomas Paine, who also gives his name to Conway Hall in London. The lectures have been given every year since 1910. Past speakers include luminaries of the humanist movement and some of the most distinguished philosophers, scientists and cultural commentators of the last century, including Bertrand Russell, Leonard and Julian Huxley, David Starkey, A.C Grayling and Steve Jones.
Dr Douglas Guilfoyle Shortlisted for Law Teacher of the Year Award
Dr Douglas Guilfoyle of UCL Laws has been shortlisted for the Oxford University Press Law Teacher of the Year Award. The six shortlisted candidates, involved in higher legal education, were chosen by a panel of judges. Dr Guilfoyle was shortlisted after meeting the following criteria:
- Displays an active interest in and development of approaches to teaching that influence, motivate and inspire students to learn
- Demonstrates commitment to and support for the development of students as individuals
- Uses effective communication skills that engage students in the learning experience
- Involvement in scholarly activities that have influenced and enhanced learning both of students and colleagues
Talking about his nomination, Dr Guilfoyle explained: "I am genuinely delighted to have been both nominated and shortlisted. I'm looking forward to the judges' visit to UCL, and the opportunity to showcase teaching at Laws." The Award, sponsored by Oxford University Press, is the only one of its kind in the UK set up specifically to reward great law teaching. The winner will be announced at the 2012 LILAC event held at the University of Warwick in February.
British Bill of Rights debated at Institute for Human Rights event
On 26 Oct, UCL's Institute of Human Rights hosted a lively evening on
the much-debated British Bill of Rights. Discussion included the
current push by Attorney General, Dominic Grieve, to use the principle
of subsidiarity to get more leeway for domestic interpretations of
European Convention rights.
Dr. Saladin Meckled-Garcia from the Institute described this as an unfortunate attempt to shift the meaning of subsidiarity from "primary responsibility for implementation to primary responsibility for interpretation" of convention rights. Colm O'Cinneide (UCL Laws) persuasively argued that expanding the margin of appreciation for Britain would open the floodgates for countries like Russia to limit human rights claims. Aileen Kavanagh (Oxford), also on the panel, warned that there was no legally expedient way to distance the UK from Strasbourg jurisprudence and described the Human Rights Act as Britain's Bill of Rights. The discussion was provocatively reported in the Guardian the next day. Members from the Government's Commission on a Bill of Rights were in attendance, to hear speakers dissect a number of proposals.
Dr Arad Reisberg appointed Distinguished Visiting Scholar at Brooklyn Law School
Dr Arad Reisberg of UCL Laws has been appointed a Distinguished Visiting Scholar at Brooklyn Law School. During his one week visit to New York, Dr Reisberg presented a paper titled ‘Access to Justice or Justice Not Accessed: Is There a Case for Public Funding of Derivative Claims?’ and sat on a panel on shareholder Litigation as part of an international symposium ‘The influence (or non-influence) of the American model of litigation in other countries’, held on 21 October 2011.
He also taught a class on the course in advanced topics in corporate law and delivered a lunchtime seminar as part of the Dennis J. Block Center for the Study of International Business Law workshop series at Brooklyn Law School.
Sir Robin Jacob Gives Testimony to Hargreaves Review of Intellectual Property 
The Rt Hon Professor Sir Robin Jacob, Sir Hugh Laddie Chair of Intellectual Property Law at UCL and Director of the Institute of Brand and Innovation Law, gave testimony on 18 October to the HOC Business, Innovation and Skills Committee's second evidence session on the Hargreaves Review of Intellectual Property. The Business, Innovation and Skills Committee is appointed by the House of Commons to examine the administration, expenditure and policy of the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) and its associated public bodies, including Ofcom and the Office of Fair Trading (OFT).
Professor John Lowry Joins Research Grants Council of Hong Kong
The Research Grants Council of Hong Kong has invited Professor John Lowry of UCL Laws to join their 2012 Research Panel, which awards funds to overseas PhD Fellows. The Research Fellowship Scheme aims to attract the best and brightest students in the world to pursue their PhD studies in Hong Kong. This important, collaborative role will foster the ongoing ties between UCL Laws and its colleagues and alumni in Hong Kong.
UCL LexisNexis Legal Education Debate 2011
What is the purpose of a qualifying law degree? Are law students being adequately prepared for legal practice? What skills will those providing legal services need in 2020? The LexisNexis Legal Education Debate, a topical event held by UCL Laws on 11 Oct, created a forum for law teachers and professionals to openly debate the purpose of academic legal education, recognising areas of commonality and of difference.
The distinguished panel of speakers included Prof Philippe Sands, UCL, Rebecca Huxley-Binns, Nottingham Trent University, Prof Stephen Mayson, Legal Services Institute, David Bickerton,Clifford Chance and Prof Richard Moorhead, Cardiff Law School. It was chaired by Dean of UCL Laws, Prof Dame Hazel Genn.
Each panel member put their views to an audience of academics, lawyers and students and informative commentary was provided by Sir Mark Potter, Co-Chair of the Legal Education and Training Review. The event was both timely and important, raising a number of topical and thought-provoking issues in anticipation of the legal education review.
Professor Joanne Scott gives Evidence to the Energy and Climate Change Select Committee
On 11 Oct, UCL Professor of European Law Joanne Scott gave evidence in Parliament to the Energy and Climate Change Select Committee. The Select Committee is investigating whether the EU emissions trading system can deliver the EU’s climate change mitigation goals in the absence of a legally-binding international emissions reduction commitment. The session explored a range of issues, including:
- The aviation sector in the EU Emissions Trading System
- Dealing with emissions from international shipping
- How the EU Emissions Trading System can help to meet the UK’s climate change targets
- The economic impacts of the EU Emissions Trading System
- Whether the EU can sustain a credible carbon price without a global deal
- How to cooperate with other countries to achieve a fair deal on climate change
Dean's LLM Welcome Party 2011
New LLM students and Faculty members kicked off the academic year in style at the UCL Laws annual Dean's Welcome party on 5 Oct. Students were welcomed to their Masters programme by Dean Professor Dame Hazel Genn, who gave a speech noting their significant achievement in joining UCL. Director of Graduate Programmes, Mark Blakely, encouraged students to make the most of their time in the Faculty, noting that "the LLM at UCL is a fantastic way to reorientate your legal career." The Dean's LLM Welcome party brought together students from over 70 countries worldwide - a truly international graduate student cohort.
Ronan McCrea appointed Academic Fellow of the Inner Temple
Dr Ronan McCrea of UCL Laws has recently been appointed, with three other prominent legal academics, as an Academic Fellow of the Honourable Society of the Inner Temple. The Academic Fellows Scheme aims to recognise the outstanding contribution of legal teaching and research of early to mid-career academics to the Bar of England and Wales. It also aims to support their research and to build stronger ties between barristers and legal academics. The Honourable Society of the Inner Temple is one of the four barrister Inns of Court and holds the exclusive responsibility to call candidates to practise at the Bar of England and Wales.
Fiona Smith awarded Research Grant to study Food Security as a Human Right
UCL Laws Senior Lecturer Fiona Smith has been awarded a grant from the Swiss Government to work on a two year project with the World Trade Institute, Switzerland, on 'Food Security as a Human Right.' The grant is for SF10,000 over 2 years and will run from Oct 2011 to end Sept 2013. Fiona is the lead researcher. She will be working with Dr Christian Haberler and Professor Christine Kauffman at the World Trade Institute.
This project explores the normative impact of human rights, in particular the right to food on the concept of food security. Its objective is to prepare the ground and contribute to a regulatory framework that integrates social and economic rights into trade and investment rules together with an appropriate mix of policy space. It will provide insights necessary so that a new conceptual framework for appropriate tools to implement food security respecting the right to food can be developed. Congratulations to Fiona.